The Ogallala Aquifer in the Great Plains of the United States is being depleted faster than it is replenished, primarily due to irrigation for corn and wheat production. Which agricultural geography concept does this situation best illustrate?
- AWater-intensive agriculture depleting a non-renewable aquifer in a semi-arid regionCorrect
- BThe green revolution, in which high-yield crop varieties sharply raised output in arid regions
- CShifting cultivation, in which farmers rotate to new plots to let the aquifer recharge naturally
- DThe tragedy of the commons, in which shared urban water supplies are overdrawn by individual users
- ESalinization, in which evaporating irrigation water leaves salts that degrade farm soils
Why A is right
The Ogallala Aquifer case is a classic example of water-intensive commercial agriculture in a semi-arid region drawing on a fossil aquifer that recharges over thousands of years. Current extraction rates vastly exceed recharge, making it effectively a non-renewable resource being depleted, raising long-term agricultural sustainability concerns.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- B
- The green revolution refers to the mid-20th-century spread of high-yield crop varieties and fertilizers, mainly in developing nations; it does not describe or explain aquifer depletion.
- C
- Shifting cultivation is a tropical land-rotation system and is not practiced in the Great Plains; rotating plots would not recharge a fossil aquifer that takes millennia to refill.
- D
- The tragedy of the commons is a related idea, but this scenario centers on agricultural irrigation, not urban water consumption, so this choice misidentifies the water use involved.
- E
- Salinization is another environmental consequence of irrigation, but it concerns salt buildup degrading soil quality, not groundwater being withdrawn faster than it recharges; a student who links 'irrigation problem' to salinization confuses soil degradation with aquifer depletion.
Read the following practice passage.
In this dry country, rain falls only a few weeks each year. When it comes, families drive their camels and goats north onto short-grass plains, where shallow pools briefly fill. As the pools shrink, they turn south again toward wells dug along a seasonal riverbed and wait out the long dry months there. Families keep herds far larger than they need for milk, since a big herd is their insurance against the bad years that arrive every decade or so. They trade milk and hides in market towns for millet. In recent years, however, fenced irrigation projects along the river have blocked several of the old routes to the dry-season wells.
Which of the following does the passage identify as a recent change threatening the herding system it describes?
- AA run of recent drought years that has shrunk the grass across the northern plains
- BNew government programs that require herding families to settle in permanent villages
- CFenced irrigation projects that have cut off older routes to the dry-season wellsCorrect
- DOvergrazing around the wells that has turned nearby pasture into bare, eroding sand
- ECommercial ranches selling cheap meat that undercut the herders in market towns
Why C is right
The passage describes pastoral nomadism: herders in an arid region move livestock between seasonal pastures (northern plains in the brief rains, riverbed wells in the dry months) and trade animal products for grain. Its last sentence names the one recent change: 'fenced irrigation projects along the river have blocked several of the old routes to the dry-season wells.' This is the land-use conflict between expanding sedentary farming and mobile herding. The other choices are real pressures on pastoralists in general, but the passage reports none of them as happening.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Drought is a real hazard for pastoral nomads, but the passage mentions bad years only as something that comes every decade or so and that large herds insure against. It reports no recent run of drought years.
- B
- Forced settlement (sedentarization) is a real pressure on pastoral nomads in many countries, but the passage says nothing about government settlement programs.
- D
- Overgrazing and desertification near water points are real problems in arid herding regions, but the passage does not describe any damage to the land around the wells.
- E
- Commercial livestock production can compete with subsistence herders, but the passage describes only trading milk and hides for millet. It mentions no ranches or price competition.