Which of the following is a limitation of the crude birth rate (CBR) as a measure of fertility?
- AIt reports births only once per decade, so it cannot capture short-term shifts in fertility
- BIt subtracts deaths from births, so it reflects natural increase rather than fertility alone
- CIt ignores the population's age and sex structure, potentially misrepresenting fertilityCorrect
- DIt records only births occurring in cities, omitting rural areas where fertility is often higher
- EIt adds net immigration to the birth count, overstating natural increase in receiving countries
Why C is right
The CBR divides total births by total population, treating all individuals equally regardless of whether they are of reproductive age. A country with a high proportion of elderly people or children will have a different CBR than one with many women of childbearing age, even if fertility behavior is identical. The total fertility rate (TFR) is a more refined measure that accounts for age structure.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because CBR is an annual rate (births per 1,000 population each year), not a once-per-decade figure.
- B
- Incorrect because this confuses CBR with the rate of natural increase (RNI = CBR - CDR); CBR counts only births per 1,000 people and never subtracts deaths.
- D
- Incorrect because CBR counts all births within a country or region, both urban and rural, not only those in cities.
- E
- Incorrect because CBR counts only births; immigration changes the total population (the denominator) but is never added to the birth count.