The table shows hypothetical data on a manufacturing firm's average rate of return on investment and the share of its new investment placed in each of four regions in 1990 and 2010. Region Q was closed to foreign investment in 1990 and opened to it in the 1990s.
| Region | Rate of return, 1990 | Rate of return, 2010 | Share of new investment, 1990 | Share of new investment, 2010 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Home region | 14% | 5% | 80% | 30% |
| Region P | 9% | 8% | 15% | 20% |
| Region Q | not open | 16% | 0% | 45% |
| Region R | 6% | 4% | 5% | 5% |
Which of the following conclusions about the firm's behavior is best supported by the data?
- AThe firm kept most of its new investment in the home region in both years because home-region returns stayed the highest of any region
- BRegion P gained the largest increase in share of new investment, showing the firm favored semiperipheral regions with stable returns
- CAs home-region returns fell, the firm moved the largest share of new investment into Region Q, which was closed in 1990 but gave the highest return by 2010Correct
- DFalling returns in Region R led the firm to pull investment out of Region R and redirect that capital back into the home region
- EBecause returns declined in every region the firm invested in during 1990, the firm reduced the share of new investment it placed outside its home region
Why C is right
The table shows returns in the firm's home region falling from 14% to 5% while its share of new investment fell from 80% to 30%. Over the same period, Region Q, which was not open to investment in 1990, took 45% of new investment and offered the highest return in 2010 (16%). This is the pattern geographers call a spatial fix: when capital builds up in an established area and stops earning a profitable return there (overaccumulation), firms move the surplus into new territories and markets to restore profits. Choice C is the only statement that matches both the falling home returns and the shift of capital toward the newly opened region.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Misreads the trend. The home region had the highest return in 1990 (14%), but by 2010 it was down to 5%, below Regions P and Q, and its share of new investment fell from 80% to 30%, which is no longer a majority.
- B
- Compares the wrong rows. Region P's share rose by only 5 percentage points (15% to 20%), while Region Q's rose by 45 points (0% to 45%), so Region P did not have the largest increase.
- D
- Makes a causal claim the table does not support. Region R's return did fall (6% to 4%), but its share of new investment stayed at 5%, and the home region's share went down, not up.
- E
- Gets the first half right but reverses the trend. Returns did fall in the home region and in Regions P and R, but the share of new investment placed outside the home region rose from 20% to 70%.