The table shows hypothetical data for five countries. It gives the share of streamed media (films, music, video) that people consume in English and the percentage of youth aged 15-24 who mainly use the local language at home.
| Country | English share of media, 2000 (%) | English share of media, 2020 (%) | Youth using local language at home, 2000 (%) | Youth using local language at home, 2020 (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| V | 20 | 35 | 80 | 72 |
| W | 10 | 55 | 90 | 62 |
| X | 15 | 20 | 85 | 83 |
| Y | 30 | 70 | 70 | 45 |
| Z | 5 | 12 | 95 | 91 |
Which of the following conclusions is best supported by the data in the table?
- ACountry Y had the lowest youth home use of the local language in 2000 and also the largest decline in that use by 2020
- BThe data prove that English-language media directly caused the decline of local-language use in all five countries
- CCountry X shows youth home use of the local language rising alongside a modest gain in English-language media share
- DCountry Z had its English-language media share more than double, which brought the largest drop in local-language use
- EThe two countries with the largest gains in English-language media share, W and Y, also had the largest drops in youth home use of the local languageCorrect
Why E is right
From the table, English media share rose by 45 points in W (10 to 55) and 40 points in Y (30 to 70), the two largest gains. The other gains were 15 (V), 7 (Z), and 5 (X). Youth home use of the local language fell by 28 points in W and 25 points in Y, also the two largest drops. The other drops were 8 (V), 4 (Z), and 2 (X). This pattern fits the cultural imperialism argument that English spreading through global media can push aside local languages. The data show a link between the two, not proof that one caused the other.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Wrong row. Y did have the lowest 2000 value (70%), but its decline (70 to 45, 25 points) is smaller than W's (90 to 62, 28 points).
- C
- Reversed trend. In Country X, youth home use of the local language fell slightly (85 to 83). It did not rise.
- D
- Confuses a ratio with a difference. Z's English share did more than double (5 to 12), but that is only a 7-point gain, and Z's drop in local-language use (4 points) is one of the smallest.
- B
- Unsupported causal leap. The table shows a correlation between the two measures. It cannot prove that one directly caused the other, and other factors such as migration, schooling, or urbanization could also play a role.