The table shows hypothetical data on daily commuters traveling from five towns to jobs in City X.
| Town | Distance from City X (km) | Town population (thousands) | Daily commuters to City X |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alda | 10 | 20 | 4,000 |
| Borin | 25 | 20 | 1,500 |
| Cassel | 50 | 20 | 400 |
| Dunmore | 50 | 80 | 1,600 |
| Elton | 100 | 80 | 300 |
Which of the following conclusions is best supported by the data in the table?
- ATown population alone explains the commuting pattern, since the two towns with 80,000 residents send the most commuters
- BAt every distance shown, smaller towns send a larger share of their residents to City X than larger towns do
- CCommuting declines in direct proportion to distance, since doubling the distance from Borin to Cassel halves the number of commuters
- DDistance matters little for larger towns, since Elton sends nearly as many commuters as Dunmore despite lying twice as far away
- EAmong towns of equal population, commuting falls steeply with distance; Alda sends ten times as many commuters as Cassel, which is five times as far awayCorrect
Why E is right
Holding population constant at 20,000 (Alda, Borin, Cassel), commuters drop from 4,000 at 10 km to 1,500 at 25 km to 400 at 50 km. Alda sends 4,000 / 400 = 10 times as many commuters as Cassel, though Cassel is only 50 / 10 = 5 times as far away. The same pattern appears for the 80,000-person towns (1,600 at 50 km vs. 300 at 100 km). This illustrates friction of distance: the cost, time, and effort of overcoming distance reduce interaction, so interaction falls off as places get farther apart.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Misreads the table: Elton has 80,000 residents but sends only 300 commuters, fewer than 20,000-person Borin (1,500), so population alone cannot explain the pattern.
- C
- Ratio error: going from Borin (25 km) to Cassel (50 km) cuts commuters from 1,500 to 400, a drop of more than 70 percent, not a halving, so the decline is steeper than proportional.
- D
- Reverses the data: Elton sends 300 commuters versus Dunmore's 1,600, barely a fifth as many, so distance matters greatly for larger towns too.
- B
- Unsupported by the shares: at 50 km, Cassel sends 400 of 20,000 residents (2 percent) and Dunmore sends 1,600 of 80,000 (2 percent), the same share, so smaller towns do not send a larger share.