The table shows hypothetical data for districts of a large city, City X, grouped by direction and distance from the central business district (CBD).
| District | Direction from CBD | Distance from CBD (km) | Median household income (city average = 100) | Housing that is self-built (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CBD | — | 0 | 120 | 2 |
| Northwest 1 | Northwest | 4 | 210 | 1 |
| Northwest 2 | Northwest | 9 | 240 | 0 |
| East 1 | East | 4 | 85 | 12 |
| East 2 | East | 9 | 45 | 58 |
| South 1 | South | 4 | 80 | 15 |
| South 2 | South | 9 | 40 | 64 |
Which of the following statements is best supported by the data in the table?
- AIncome rises with distance only in the northwest, while the outer east and south districts are poorest and mostly self-built, matching the Griffin-Ford modelCorrect
- BIncome rises with distance from the CBD in every direction, so the wealthiest residents occupy the outermost ring, matching the Burgess model
- CThe high-income districts form separate nodes that are not adjacent to the CBD or to each other, matching the multiple nuclei model
- DHigh-income wedges of similar income extend from the CBD in all three directions, with little self-built housing, matching the Hoyt sector model
- EOuter districts in every direction earn more than inner districts, like edge cities ringing the central city, matching the peripheral model
Why A is right
Reading the table by direction: in the northwest, income climbs from 210 at 4 km to 240 at 9 km with almost no self-built housing, a single high-income corridor running out from the CBD. In the east and south, income falls with distance (85 to 45; 80 to 40) and self-built housing climbs to 58% and 64% in the outer districts. A single elite spine from the CBD with poor, largely self-built (informal) settlements on the periphery in other directions is the pattern of the Griffin-Ford model. The data rule out a uniform outward income gradient (Burgess), multiple elite wedges (Hoyt), separate nodes (multiple nuclei), and an affluent outer ring (peripheral).
Why the other 4 choices miss
- B
- Misreads the trend as uniform: income rises with distance only in the northwest (210 to 240); in the east (85 to 45) and south (80 to 40) it falls, so the wealthy do not occupy the whole outer ring.
- C
- Wrong reading of the layout: the two high-income districts are both in the northwest, adjacent to each other and running outward from the CBD, forming one corridor rather than separate, isolated nodes.
- D
- Treats every direction as an elite wedge: only the northwest has high incomes; the east and south have below-average incomes and self-built housing shares of 12-64%, not little self-built housing.
- E
- Overgeneralizes from the northwest row: the outer east (45) and south (40) districts earn less than their inner districts (85 and 80), so there is no affluent ring of edge cities around the core.