A researcher uses a proportional symbol map to show the population size of capital cities in Africa, with circle size proportional to population. Lagos is shown with a very large circle, Cairo with a large circle, and Nairobi with a medium circle. What limitation of this cartographic technique should the researcher acknowledge?
- AProportional symbols can represent only physical phenomena such as elevation or rainfall, and are unsuited to human data like population totals
- BCircle sizes show population density rather than totals, so small-area cities look larger than they are
- CThe technique always requires a logarithmic scale, since a linear circle-size scale inevitably distorts the largest population values
- DSymbols may overlap where cities cluster, hiding smaller circles and making exact values hard to readCorrect
- EThe method can display no more than ten symbols before the map becomes unreadable and has to be simplified
Why D is right
A key limitation of proportional symbol maps is symbol overlap in regions with many closely spaced data points. When multiple large cities are close together, their symbols may overlap, making it difficult to read individual values or even see smaller symbols hidden behind larger ones. This is a practical limitation the researcher should acknowledge.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Proportional symbol maps are widely used for human data, including population, GDP, and trade volumes. They are not restricted to physical phenomena like elevation or rainfall.
- B
- This confuses proportional symbol maps with choropleth density maps. The circles here are scaled to absolute population totals, as the stem states. They do not show density, so a city's land area has no effect on its circle size.
- C
- Proportional symbol maps do not require logarithmic scales by default. A logarithmic scale may be chosen when data ranges are very large, but a linear scale is common and not inherently distorting, so it is a design choice, not a requirement.
- E
- Proportional symbol maps can display any number of data points — there is no ten-symbol limit. Maps with hundreds of proportional symbols are common in geographic research.