A geographer studying the development impact of microfinance programs documents a significant finding: in regions with strong microfinance penetration, local businesses that borrowed showed improved incomes, but overall regional income inequality increased. Which geographic outcome does this finding MOST directly illustrate?
- AMicrofinance raised individual borrower incomes yet widened inequality because gains concentrated among the entrepreneurially capable rather than the poorest householdsCorrect
- BMicrofinance generated spread effects, as gains to borrowers diffused outward to neighboring households and narrowed regional income gaps
- CMicrofinance triggered resource-curse dynamics, as the inflow of loan capital reduced incentives for households to diversify their income sources
- DJust-in-time manufacturing spread alongside microfinance, and the resulting labor competition drove down wages for local borrowers
- EMicrofinance ultimately failed in these regions because most borrowers defaulted, eroding the pooled capital available for future lending
Why A is right
This finding reflects a documented critique of microfinance: the 'cherrypicking' problem. Microfinance tends to benefit those who are poor but entrepreneurially capable — not the poorest of the poor, who may lack the skills, market access, or risk tolerance to use loans productively. If the already-better-off poor benefit disproportionately, inequality within the target population can increase even as average incomes rise.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- B
- Spread effects (Myrdal) describe growth diffusing outward and reducing disparities, but the scenario explicitly reports that regional income inequality increased. This reflects backwash-style concentration of gains, not spread.
- C
- Microfinance provides small individual loans; it does not create the commodity-export capital floods associated with the resource curse, and the scenario shows borrower incomes rising, not diversification collapsing.
- D
- Just-in-time manufacturing is unrelated to microfinance program dynamics and is not mentioned or implied in the scenario.
- E
- The scenario states borrowers showed improved incomes, indicating repayment was likely; the finding concerns rising inequality, not widespread default.