A practice passage describes a neighborhood on the edge of a mid-sized city.
Two years ago, a full-service supermarket opened within a half mile of most homes, and a weekend produce stand operates nearby. Yet a local clinic reports that residents' diets and rates of diet-related illness have barely changed. Along the main commercial corridor, residents pass fourteen fast-food restaurants and nine convenience stores, most open late and selling inexpensive packaged snacks and sugary drinks. Many residents say they stop at these outlets on the walk home from work or school because they are closer to transit stops, faster, and cheaper per meal than buying groceries and cooking.
Which of the following conclusions about the neighborhood is best supported by the passage?
- AResidents eat poorly mainly because the nearest store selling fresh produce is too far away to reach without a car
- BBuilding a full-service supermarket within walking distance of most homes would do the most to improve local diets
- COpening the supermarket raised diet quality, showing that physical access to healthy food is enough to change diets
- DLocal eating habits chiefly reflect the cultural food preferences that immigrant groups brought to the corridor
- EDiet quality depends on how heavily unhealthy food outlets outnumber healthy ones, not only on whether healthy food is nearbyCorrect
Why E is right
The passage says a supermarket and a produce stand are already within a half mile of most homes, yet diets have barely changed. Meanwhile, 23 fast-food and convenience outlets crowd the corridor residents walk every day, and residents choose them because they are closer, faster, and cheaper. That pattern illustrates a food swamp: unhealthy outlets heavily outnumbering healthy ones shapes diet quality even when healthy food can physically be reached. This goes beyond the food-desert idea, which focuses on distance to healthy food.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- This is the food-desert explanation (too far from fresh produce), but the passage says a supermarket is within a half mile of most homes, so distance is not the problem it describes.
- B
- Food-desert policy often recommends opening a nearby supermarket, but the passage says one already opened two years ago and diets barely changed, so the passage undercuts this conclusion.
- D
- Cultural food preferences can shape diets, but the passage never mentions immigrant groups or cultural traditions; the reasons residents give are convenience, speed, and price.
- C
- This reverses the passage: the clinic reports that diets and diet-related illness barely changed after the supermarket opened, so access alone was not enough.