The table shows hypothetical data from a survey of 400 adults in a rural district who considered moving to a large city within the past five years but decided to stay. Each respondent gave one main reason for not moving.
| Main reason for not moving to the city | Percent of respondents |
|---|---|
| Cost of transport and a housing deposit in the city | 21 |
| City residence-permit rules for newcomers | 16 |
| Owns farmland or has steady work in the village | 19 |
| High rents and few job openings in the city | 17 |
| Respondent's age or health | 15 |
| Unwilling to leave the familiar for an uncertain outcome | 12 |
If the reasons are grouped according to the four elements of Everett Lee's migration model, which of the following conclusions is best supported by the data?
- AGrouped by element of the model, intervening obstacles account for a larger share of respondents than any of the other three elementsCorrect
- BPersonal factors account for a smaller share of respondents than factors associated with the area of origin
- CConditions in the city were the main reason given by a larger share of respondents than any other single reason
- DFactors associated with the area of origin were the main reason for more than one-third of respondents
- ELowering the cost of moving would lead a majority of the respondents to migrate to the city
Why A is right
Lee's model sorts migration decisions into factors at the origin, factors at the destination, intervening obstacles, and personal factors. Sorting the table's rows: intervening obstacles = moving costs (21) + residence-permit rules (16) = 37%; personal factors = age or health (15) + unwillingness to face an uncertain outcome (12) = 27%; origin factors = farmland or steady village work = 19%; destination factors = high rents and few jobs in the city = 17%. Intervening obstacles are therefore the largest group, so A is supported. B reverses personal vs. origin, C misidentifies the largest single row, D wrongly merges origin and destination rows, and E draws a causal conclusion the survey cannot support.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- B
- Reverses the comparison: personal factors (age or health 15 + unwillingness to face an uncertain outcome 12 = 27%) exceed factors at the origin (farmland or steady village work = 19%).
- C
- Misreads the rows: conditions in the city (high rents and few jobs) were cited by 17%, less than the single most common reason, the cost of transport and a housing deposit (21%).
- D
- Origin factors account for only 19%; reaching more than one-third requires wrongly adding the destination row (17%) to the origin row, treating push and pull factors as one element.
- E
- An unsupported causal leap: moving costs were the main reason for only 21% of respondents, and the survey does not show what respondents would do if costs fell.