Read the following practice passage.
City planners in a mid-sized city counted visitors at four new parks and declared the parks a success because total attendance rose every year. A researcher who reviewed the project argued that the counts concealed more than they revealed. A tally of visitors, the researcher noted, cannot show who stays away, why some people leave before dark, or which paths they quietly avoid. In the researcher's view, the more important questions concern how residents themselves understand these spaces: where they feel welcome, where they feel watched, and how those feelings shape their daily routines.
Which research approach would the researcher described in the passage most likely favor for a follow-up study of the four parks?
- ARegression modeling of yearly attendance counts against park size, amenities, and distance to transit stops
- BSatellite image analysis measuring tree canopy and lighting coverage within each of the four parks
- CAutomated visitor counters at every entrance to track attendance changes by month and season
- DIn-depth interviews with residents and repeated observation of how people use the parks at different hoursCorrect
- EGIS network analysis of walking distances from each neighborhood to the closest park entrance
Why D is right
The passage rejects attendance counts because they cannot reveal who stays away, why people leave before dark, or where residents feel welcome or watched. Those are questions about lived experience and perception, which call for qualitative methods: in-depth interviews let residents describe their routines and feelings, and repeated observation across the day shows how use changes (for example, after dark). This people-centered approach is typical of feminist and humanistic geography. The other choices all rely on counts, physical measurements, or distances, which the researcher argues miss what matters.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Regression on attendance counts is still built on the visitor tallies the researcher says conceal more than they reveal; it cannot capture how residents feel or why some stay away.
- C
- Finer-grained visitor counters repeat the planners' headcount approach that the passage criticizes; more detailed counts still cannot show who avoids the parks or why.
- E
- Walking-distance analysis measures physical access, a plausible misreading of 'who stays away'; the passage locates the problem in how residents feel within the spaces, not in how far they live from them.
- B
- Measuring canopy and lighting describes physical features of the parks, but the researcher's questions are about residents' own perceptions of welcome and surveillance, which imagery cannot record.