A researcher wants to study the spatial association between fast-food restaurants and rates of obesity at the county level in the United States. She finds a strong positive correlation. Which critical limitation should she acknowledge?
- ASpatial association is purely descriptive and cannot incorporate quantitative measures such as correlation coefficients or regression
- BSpatial association does not establish causation; confounding variables such as income and education may explain the patternCorrect
- CBecause the correlation is statistically strong, it confirms that fast-food access is the direct cause of the obesity rates observed
- DCounty-level data is too fine-grained and should be aggregated to the state level before any valid spatial pattern emerges
- EA positive correlation means the two phenomena are spatially dispersed, so they rarely occur together in the same counties
Why B is right
Spatial association identifies co-occurrence of phenomena but does not establish causation. The observed correlation between fast-food density and obesity could be driven by confounding variables like poverty, education levels, or lack of healthcare access that are associated with both fast-food prevalence and obesity rates.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because spatial association routinely relies on quantitative methods, including correlation coefficients, regression analysis, and geographic information systems.
- C
- Incorrect because a strong correlation does not confirm causation; the spatial co-occurrence of fast-food restaurants and obesity could reflect confounding factors rather than a direct causal link.
- D
- Incorrect because aggregating to a coarser scale reduces analytical precision and can introduce the modifiable areal unit problem; county-level data is an appropriate scale for this analysis.
- E
- Incorrect because it reverses the meaning of a positive spatial association: a strong positive correlation means counties with more fast-food restaurants also tend to have higher obesity rates, so the two co-occur rather than being dispersed. Students who confuse correlation direction with spatial distribution patterns (clustered vs. dispersed) may choose this.