The table shows hypothetical data on the same set of votes cast in one city, grouped into spatial units in four different ways by a political analyst.
| Grouping scheme | Number of units | Units with a Republican majority | Units with a Democratic majority | Citywide Republican share of the vote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Large districts | 4 | 4 | 0 | 54% |
| Medium districts | 8 | 5 | 3 | 54% |
| Census tracts | 16 | 8 | 8 | 54% |
| Precincts | 32 | 15 | 17 | 54% |
Which of the following conclusions is best supported by the data in the table?
- ARepublican support in the city fell from the 4-district scheme to the 32-precinct scheme, as fewer units recorded Republican majorities
- BSince all 4 large districts had Republican majorities, a majority of voters in each smaller unit also voted Republican
- CThe citywide Republican share is the same in every scheme, yet the count of Republican-majority units changes as the same votes are split into smaller unitsCorrect
- DUnder the 32-precinct scheme, Democrats won a majority of the citywide vote because they carried 17 of the 32 precincts
- EThe 16-tract scheme gives the most accurate result, because it is the only scheme that splits the units evenly between parties
Why C is right
In the table, the citywide Republican share is 54% in all four rows, so the underlying votes never change. What changes is the unit-level result: Republicans carry 4 of 4 large districts but only 15 of 32 precincts. When the analysis depends on how boundaries are drawn and how large the units are, rather than on the data themselves, that is the modifiable areal unit problem (MAUP).
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- This misreads the table. The number of Republican-majority units falls (4 to 15 of 32 as a proportion), but the citywide Republican share stays at 54% in every row. Support did not change, only the way the votes were grouped.
- B
- This is the ecological fallacy, and the table contradicts it: under the precinct scheme, 17 of the 32 smaller units had Democratic majorities.
- D
- This confuses units won with votes won. The Precincts row still shows a 54% citywide Republican share, so carrying more precincts did not give Democrats a citywide majority.
- E
- An even 8-8 split is not evidence of accuracy. The table gives no basis for ranking schemes, and every scheme reports the same 54% citywide share; the 16-tract scheme is just one more way of grouping the same votes.