A geographer used drone-mounted LiDAR to map elevation to centimeter precision on five islets of a Pacific atoll. The table shows hypothetical data from that survey.
| Islet | Land area (ha) | Mean elevation above high tide (m) | % of land less than 1 m above high tide | % of land less than 2 m above high tide | Population |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ana | 120 | 3.4 | 8 | 30 | 1,900 |
| Bera | 45 | 1.3 | 41 | 88 | 650 |
| Coro | 210 | 2.9 | 5 | 18 | 400 |
| Dalo | 80 | 1.8 | 25 | 61 | 2,400 |
| Eru | 30 | 1.1 | 55 | 94 | 120 |
Which of the following conclusions is best supported by the data in the table?
- AIf residents are spread evenly across each islet, Dalo has the most people living on land less than 1 m above high tideCorrect
- BEru has the most residents living on land less than 1 m above high tide, since its low-lying share is the largest
- CAna is less exposed to a 2 m rise than Coro is, since Ana has a smaller share of its land below 2 m
- DEvery islet with a higher mean elevation has a smaller share of its land lying less than 2 m above high tide
- EEru contains more hectares of land less than 1 m above high tide than Dalo does, given Eru's higher share
Why A is right
The precise elevation data from the LiDAR survey let the geographer combine the share of low-lying land with population. If people are spread evenly, the number of residents on land less than 1 m above high tide is: Ana 8% x 1,900 = 152; Bera 41% x 650 = about 267; Coro 5% x 400 = 20; Dalo 25% x 2,400 = 600; Eru 55% x 120 = 66. Dalo has by far the most people at risk even though Eru and Bera have larger low-lying shares. This is the kind of vulnerability assessment that centimeter-level elevation data make possible.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- B
- Confuses a percentage with a count. Eru has the largest low-lying share (55%), but with only 120 residents that is about 66 people, far fewer than Dalo's roughly 600.
- C
- Misreads the rows. Ana has 30% of its land below 2 m and Coro has only 18%, so Ana's share is larger, not smaller.
- D
- An overgeneralization the table contradicts. Ana's mean elevation (3.4 m) is higher than Coro's (2.9 m), yet Ana has a larger share of land below 2 m (30% vs. 18%). A mean can hide how elevation is distributed.
- E
- Confuses share with area. Eru: 55% of 30 ha = 16.5 ha. Dalo: 25% of 80 ha = 20 ha. Dalo has more low-lying hectares despite its smaller percentage.