Skip to content
AP Human Geography · Agriculture and Rural Land-Use Patterns and Processes

Smallholder

Smallholder appears in 12 reviewed AP Human Geography questions and sits in Agriculture and Rural Land-Use Patterns and Processes. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Smallholder is tested

Example 1Medium
A country's land reform law sets a ceiling on farm sizes, requires landowners above the maximum to sell surplus land to the government at regulated prices, and offers that land to landless rural workers at subsidized rates. The table shows hypothetical data for four of the country's provinces in the year the law took effect (Year 0) and ten years later (Year 10). | Province | Farmland in estates over 500 ha, Year 0 (%) | Farmland in estates over 500 ha, Year 10 (%) | Rural households that are landless, Year 0 (%) | Rural households that are landless, Year 10 (%) | |---|---|---|---|---| | North | 72 | 31 | 45 | 18 | | Central | 58 | 52 | 38 | 35 | | South | 65 | 40 | 41 | 30 | | Coast | 30 | 22 | 20 | 17 | Which of the following conclusions is BEST supported by the data in the table?
  1. ACoast had the largest decrease in estate land share, since its estates were the smallest at the start
  2. BCentral had the largest drop in landless households even though its estate share barely changed
  3. CLandlessness fell by roughly the same number of points in all four provinces over the ten years
  4. DSouth's estate land share fell further than North's, but its share of landless households fell less
  5. ENorth had both the largest drop in estate land share and the largest drop in landless households of the four provincesCorrect

Why E is right

Read the changes in the table. Estate land share fell 41 points in North (72 to 31), 25 in South, 8 in Coast and 6 in Central. Landless households fell 27 points in North (45 to 18), 11 in South and 3 each in Central and Coast. North has the largest decline in both columns, so E is supported. The pattern fits the expected geographic outcome of land redistribution: where the reform broke up the most large-estate land, the most land went to smallholders, and rural land inequality and landlessness fell the most. Where little estate land changed hands (Central), landlessness barely moved.
Why the other 4 choices miss
A
Coast's estate share fell only 8 points (30 to 22), less than North (41) or South (25). This answer confuses having the lowest starting level with having the largest decline.
B
Central's landless share fell only 3 points (38 to 35), tied with Coast for the smallest drop. The claim misreads the row, even though it correctly notes that Central's estate share barely changed (6 points).
C
The declines ranged from 27 points (North) to 3 points (Central and Coast), so they were far from equal. Only the direction of change is the same in every province.
D
This reverses the comparison. South's estate share fell 25 points, while North's fell 41.
Example 2Harder
The table shows hypothetical data for five rice-importing countries between Year 1 and Year 5. | Country | Rice import tariff, Year 1 to Year 5 (%) | Farm-gate rice price, Year 5 ($/ton) | Smallholder production cost, Year 5 ($/ton) | Change in rice-farming households, Year 1-5 (%) | Change in urban share of population, Year 1-5 (percentage points) | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | V | 45 to 45 | 410 | 350 | -2 | +1 | | W | 50 to 0 | 300 | 370 | -24 | +7 | | X | 40 to 0 | 380 | 330 | -3 | +2 | | Y | 35 to 35 | 290 | 360 | -20 | +6 | | Z | 30 to 0 | 310 | 340 | -4 | +1 | Which country's data best support the claim that eliminating rice import tariffs can push domestic prices below smallholder production costs and drive rural-to-urban migration?
  1. ACountry Z, where the tariff fell to zero, the farm-gate price fell below cost, and the urban share rose 7 points
  2. BCountry Y, where the tariff fell to zero, the farm-gate price fell below cost, and rice households fell by a fifth
  3. CCountry X, where the tariff fell to zero, the farm-gate price fell below cost, and rice households fell by 24 percent
  4. DCountry W, where the tariff fell to zero, the farm-gate price fell $70 below cost, rice households fell 24 percent, and the urban share rose 7 pointsCorrect
  5. ECountry V, where the farm-gate price fell $60 below cost and rice households declined while the urban share rose

Why D is right

Only Country W shows all three parts of the claim in the table. Its tariff went from 50 percent to 0. Its Year 5 farm-gate price ($300) is $70 below smallholder production cost ($370). Rice-farming households fell 24 percent while the urban share rose 7 points, which is consistent with farmers leaving agriculture for cities. This matches the pattern geographers describe when cheap, often subsidized, imported rice enters a liberalized market and undercuts smallholders. Z and X also removed tariffs but show little household loss or urbanization, and X's price stays above cost. Y shows displacement without any tariff change, and V shows neither liberalization nor displacement.
Why the other 4 choices miss
A
Wrong-row misreading: Z did drop its tariff and its price ($310) is below cost ($340), but its urban share rose only 1 point and rice households fell just 4 percent. The +7 belongs to Country W, so Z shows no clear migration.
B
Unsupported causal leap: Y's price ($290) is below cost ($360) and households fell 20 percent, but Y's tariff stayed at 35 percent. Y's decline cannot be credited to tariff elimination.
C
Misreads X: X removed its tariff, but its farm-gate price ($380) stays above production cost ($330), and households fell only 3 percent. The 24 percent figure belongs to Country W.
E
Reverses V's numbers: V's price ($410) is $60 above cost, not below. V kept its 45 percent tariff, and its households and urban share barely changed.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Agriculture and Rural Land-Use Patterns and Processes.