The table shows hypothetical data on five new suburban housing developments on the edge of a desert city in the southwestern United States.
| Development | Distinct house floor plans offered | Businesses that are national chains (%) | Landscaping using native desert plants (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mesa Vista | 4 | 88 | 10 |
| Saguaro Ridge | 22 | 35 | 70 |
| Copper Flats | 6 | 85 | 65 |
| Desert Bloom | 18 | 90 | 12 |
| Adobe Wells | 5 | 40 | 8 |
A geographer argues that one of these developments has a built landscape that could be dropped into almost any metropolitan area in the country, with little that reflects its local setting. Based on the data, which development most strongly supports this argument, and why?
- ADesert Bloom, because it has the highest share of businesses that are national chains
- BSaguaro Ridge, because it offers the largest number of distinct floor plans
- CCopper Flats, because it combines very few floor plans with a high share of businesses that are national chains
- DMesa Vista, because it has the fewest floor plans, a high chain share, and little native landscapingCorrect
- EAdobe Wells, because it has few floor plans and the smallest share of native landscaping
Why D is right
The geographer is describing what Edward Relph called placelessness: a landscape built from national templates rather than local conditions, so it could exist anywhere. Three columns in the table measure this: few distinct floor plans (standardized housing), a high share of national chains (standardized commerce), and little native landscaping (no tie to the desert setting). Only Mesa Vista scores low on local distinctiveness in all three: the fewest floor plans (4), 88% chains, and only 10% native landscaping. Each other development keeps at least one strong local element. Desert Bloom has housing variety, Copper Flats has native landscaping, Adobe Wells has local businesses, and Saguaro Ridge is the most locally distinctive overall.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- This choice relies on one column. Desert Bloom has the highest chain share (90%), but it offers 18 distinct floor plans, so its housing is far less standardized than Mesa Vista's. Mesa Vista lacks local character on all three measures.
- B
- This reverses the relationship. Saguaro Ridge has the most floor plan variety (22), a low chain share (35%), and mostly native landscaping (70%), so it is the MOST locally distinctive development in the table.
- C
- Copper Flats has standardized housing and many chain stores, but 65% of its landscaping uses native desert plants, which ties it to its local setting. Mesa Vista does not have this local element.
- E
- Adobe Wells has few floor plans and little native landscaping, but only 40% of its businesses are national chains. Its local commercial character means it does not fit the 'could be anywhere' argument as well as Mesa Vista.