The table shows hypothetical data on five districts of a European city, including its historic canal ring.
| District | Residents per hectare | Land in mixed-use parcels (%) | Trips made on foot or by bicycle (%) | Average block length (m) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Historic Canal Ring | 120 | 68 | 71 | 90 |
| Garden Village (1920s) | 60 | 15 | 38 | 180 |
| Ring Suburb (1960s) | 45 | 8 | 22 | 310 |
| Business Park (1980s) | 5 | 3 | 9 | 450 |
| Waterfront Infill (2010s) | 110 | 61 | 64 | 105 |
Which of the following conclusions is best supported by the data in the table?
- AThe 1920s Garden Village comes closest to the canal ring on every measure, showing that early planned suburbs kept its compact, walkable form.
- BThe 2010s Waterfront Infill comes closest to the canal ring on every measure, suggesting that recent development has deliberately adopted its compact, mixed-use, walkable form.Correct
- CDistricts with higher residential density have a lower share of trips made on foot or by bicycle, as the 1960s Ring Suburb illustrates.
- DThe Business Park has less than one-tenth the share of mixed-use land that the 1920s Garden Village has, reflecting its single-use zoning.
- EThe share of mixed-use land rises with each later era of construction, from the Garden Village to the Ring Suburb to the Waterfront Infill.
Why B is right
Reading the table row by row, the 2010s Waterfront Infill is closest to the Historic Canal Ring on all four measures: density (110 vs. 120 residents/ha), mixed-use land (61% vs. 68%), walk/bike trips (64% vs. 71%), and block length (105 m vs. 90 m). The older suburbs and the business park depart sharply from the canal ring's pattern. This supports the conclusion that recent development has returned to the compact, mixed-use, walkable, human-scaled form of historic cores, the form that new urbanism promotes as a reaction against car-oriented, single-use (Euclidean) zoning of mid-20th-century suburbs.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Wrong row: the Garden Village (60 residents/ha, 15% mixed-use, 38% walk/bike, 180 m blocks) is far from the canal ring on every measure; the Waterfront Infill is much closer on all four.
- C
- Reversed relationship: in the table, denser districts have HIGHER walk/bike shares (canal ring 120/ha and 71%; Ring Suburb 45/ha and only 22%).
- D
- Ratio misread: the Business Park's 3% is one-fifth of the Garden Village's 15%, not less than one-tenth.
- E
- Reversed/unsupported trend: mixed-use share falls from 15% (1920s) to 8% (1960s) before rising to 61% (2010s), so it does not rise with each later era.