Skip to content

Free-response practice

The Experimental Design and Analysis FRQ

10 points2 original prompts4 scored examples

The Experimental Design and Analysis question is question 3 of the four free-response questions in Section II of the AP Physics 1 exam, and that section counts for 50% of your score. This question is worth 10 of the section's 40 points, so it carries about 12.5% of your whole exam. Section II gives you 95 minutes for all four questions, so plan on about 24 minutes for this one, and use your calculator and the equation sheet freely.

On this page · 6 sections

The question puts you in a lab, where you get a setup, a goal, and either a list of equipment or permission to use standard school lab gear. The goal is usually to determine one physical quantity, such as a spring constant, a coefficient of friction or the rotational inertia of a wheel. Most versions run in three stages. First you describe a procedure that would collect useful data. Then you are handed a data table and must choose what to graph so the points fall on a straight line, after which you plot those points, draw a best-fit line, and use its slope to calculate the target quantity. Last, a follow-up part changes one condition or tests a claim, and you must justify your answer with physics.

Readers score analytically, one point at a time, and each point stands on its own. A procedure earns credit when another student could repeat it from your words alone, which means stating what you measure, which instrument measures it, and exactly how you use that instrument. The graph earns credit for labeled, evenly scaled axes, accurately plotted points and one straight line that balances the scatter. The calculation must use the slope of your drawn line, so you may use data points only if they sit on that line, and two points far apart work best. If an early part goes wrong, keep going, because later points are often awarded for work that is consistent with your own earlier result.

The rubric, in plain terms

10 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Procedure: quantities and tools1 pt

Name every quantity you must measure and the specific instrument for each one, such as the compression x with a ruler and the rise height h with a meterstick and slow-motion video. If the analysis depends on a quantity you never explain how to measure, this point is lost.

Procedure: a method that gives valid data1 pt

Explain how each measurement is actually taken so it means what the analysis needs. Say where you measure from, what you hold constant, and how raw readings become the graphed quantity, for example a = 2D/t² for a block released from rest. "Measure how high it goes" is too vague to earn it.

Procedure: reducing uncertainty1 pt

Vary the independent variable over several values (five or more is safe), and also repeat trials at each value and average them. Another concrete step can substitute for repeated trials, such as frame-by-frame video analysis or a longer timed distance, but one run per setting with no other step does not earn it.

Linearization choice1 pt

Use the physics relationship that governs the setup to pick two quantities whose graph is a straight line with the target quantity inside the slope, such as h versus x² for a spring launch. The correct pair earns the point, and the calculated values go in the table.

Plotting1 pt

Label both axes with the quantity and its units, use an even scale that spreads the data over at least half the grid, and plot every point in the correct position.

Best-fit line1 pt

Draw one straight line that balances the points, with some above and some below it. Connecting the dots, drawing a curve, or forcing the line through a point the data do not support will lose this point.

What the slope means1 pt

Write what the slope equals in terms of the target quantity and known values, starting from a correct physics relationship. For a spring launching a ball upward, that means slope = k/(2mg), because the stored energy is ½kx².

Calculation from the slope1 pt

Find the slope from two points on your drawn line, spaced well apart, then solve for the target quantity and give a correct value with correct units. A data point counts only if your line runs through it. A value that follows correctly from an error in your own slope relationship can still earn this point; a unit-conversion slip cannot.

Claim or prediction1 pt

Give the correct answer to the follow-up question, whether that means stating if a slope or intercept increases, decreases or stays the same, predicting the value it should have, or deciding whether a claim is correct.

Justification1 pt

Support the claim with physics, either by pointing to where the changed quantity appears in your slope or intercept expression or by making an energy or force argument. Restating the prediction in different words earns nothing.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

Finding the spring constant of a toy launcher

A toy launcher has a vertical spring inside a tube. A student compresses the spring by a distance x, rests a small ball of mass m = 0.050 kg on top of it, and releases it from rest. The ball rises straight up out of the tube, and the student wants to determine the spring constant k of the spring. Available equipment: a ruler, a meterstick, an electronic balance, a stopwatch and a phone camera that records slow-motion video at 240 frames per second. Assume the spring's mass, friction in the tube and air resistance are all negligible. Use g = 10 m/s².

  1. (a)Describe an experimental procedure the student could use to collect data that would allow k to be determined. State which quantities are measured, which equipment measures each one, and how the equipment is used. Include any steps that would reduce experimental uncertainty. [3 pts]
  2. (b)The student measures the maximum height h the ball reaches above its release position for five compressions. Results: x = 0.020 m, h = 0.07 m; x = 0.030 m, h = 0.17 m; x = 0.040 m, h = 0.30 m; x = 0.050 m, h = 0.47 m; x = 0.060 m, h = 0.69 m. Indicate which quantities should be graphed to produce a straight line whose slope could be used to determine k. Calculate and record any values you need to plot. [1 pt]
  3. (c)On a grid, plot the data for the quantities you chose in part (b), labeling the axes with quantities, units and an appropriate scale, and then draw a best-fit line for the data. [2 pts]
  4. (d)Using the slope of your best-fit line, calculate an experimental value for the spring constant k. [2 pts]
  5. (e)The student repeats the experiment with the same spring and the same five compressions, but uses a ball of mass 2m. Predict how the slope of the new best-fit line compares with the slope of your line in part (c), and justify your prediction. [2 pts]
Prompt 2

Measuring the rotational inertia of a lab flywheel

A solid disk (a lab flywheel) is mounted on a fixed horizontal axle with negligible friction. A light string is wrapped around the disk's hub, which has radius R = 5.0 cm, and a block of mass m hangs from the free end of the string. When the block is released from rest, it falls and the disk spins faster and faster, and the string does not slip on the hub. A group of students wants to determine the rotational inertia I of the disk about its axle. For this setup, the magnitude of the block's acceleration is a = mg / (m + I/R²). Available equipment: hooked masses from 0.10 kg to 1.0 kg, an electronic balance, a meterstick, a stopwatch and a motion detector. Use g = 10 m/s².

  1. (a)Describe an experimental procedure the students could use to measure the acceleration of the block for several different hanging masses. State which quantities are measured, which equipment measures each one, and how the equipment is used. Include any steps that would reduce experimental uncertainty. [3 pts]
  2. (b)The students collect these results. m = 0.20 kg, a = 0.88 m/s²; m = 0.25 kg, a = 1.08 m/s²; m = 0.40 kg, a = 1.63 m/s²; m = 0.50 kg, a = 1.96 m/s²; m = 1.00 kg, a = 3.21 m/s². Indicate which quantities should be graphed to produce a straight line whose slope could be used to determine I. Calculate and record any values you need to plot. [1 pt]
  3. (c)On a grid, plot the data for the quantities you chose in part (b), labeling the axes with quantities, units and an appropriate scale, and then draw a best-fit line for the data. [2 pts]
  4. (d)Using the slope of your best-fit line, calculate an experimental value for the rotational inertia I of the disk. [2 pts]
  5. (e)Predict the value of the vertical intercept of your best-fit line if the relationship given above is correct. Justify your prediction, and state whether your graph supports it. [2 pts]

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

Finding the spring constant of a toy launcher · high-scoring response10/10

(a) First, measure the ball's mass on the electronic balance to check that it is 0.050 kg. Tape the meterstick vertically to the wall right next to the launcher. Use the ruler to measure the position of the top of the spring when it is relaxed, then push the ball down and measure the top again, so the difference between the two readings is the compression x. Film each launch in slow motion with the camera held level with the top of the flight, so there is no angle error when reading the meterstick. Step through the video frame by frame to find the highest point, and calculate h as the height of the bottom of the ball at its highest point minus the height of the bottom of the ball at release. Use 5 compressions from 2 cm to 6 cm, and do 3 launches at each compression and average the heights.

(b) The elastic energy stored in the spring turns into gravitational potential energy at the top, so ½kx² = mgh, which rearranges to h = (k/2mg)x². Graph h on the vertical axis and x² on the horizontal axis, using the x² values 4.0 × 10⁻⁴, 9.0 × 10⁻⁴, 1.6 × 10⁻³, 2.5 × 10⁻³ and 3.6 × 10⁻³ m².

(c) [Graph: horizontal axis x² (× 10⁻⁴ m²) from 0 to 40 in steps of 5. Vertical axis h (m) from 0 to 0.80 in steps of 0.10. All five points are plotted, and a straight line is drawn through the middle of the points that crosses the vertical axis just below the origin, at about −0.007 m, with points scattered on both sides of it.]

(d) I picked two points on my line that are far apart: (10 × 10⁻⁴ m², 0.186 m) and (35 × 10⁻⁴ m², 0.668 m). Slope = (0.668 − 0.186)/(0.0035 − 0.0010) = 0.482/0.0025 = 193 m⁻¹. Since slope = k/(2mg), k = 2mg × slope = 2(0.050)(10)(193) = 193 N/m.

(e) The slope will be half as big, about 96 m⁻¹. At each compression the same spring stores the same energy ½kx², and all of that energy becomes mgh at the top, so if m doubles, h has to be half as big. In the slope expression k/(2mg), m is in the denominator, so doubling m halves the slope.

How it scored

1/1r1 — The response names x with the ruler, h with the meterstick and slow-motion video, and m with the balance, so every quantity the analysis uses has a measuring instrument attached to it.
1/1r2 — It defines x as the difference between two readings and measures h from the release position, which is exactly the height the energy equation needs. Reading the peak frame by frame makes the method workable, because the whole flight lasts well under a second and the ball stays near its highest point only briefly.
1/1r3 — Five compressions with three launches at each, averaged, plus a level camera to remove parallax, is more than enough to earn this point.
1/1r4 — Graphing h versus x² is the correct pair, and the student shows where it comes from by starting from conservation of energy. The x² values are calculated and recorded as the part requires.
1/1r5 — Both axes carry the quantity, its units and an even scale, and the plotted data fill most of the grid.
1/1r6 — There is one straight line with points on both sides of it. The student did not force it through the origin, which is correct because the data place the intercept slightly below zero.
1/1r7 — The statement slope = k/(2mg) follows directly from the energy relationship ½kx² = mgh.
1/1r8 — The slope comes from two points on the drawn line that are spaced far apart, and the final value of 193 N/m is correct and carries the right units.
1/1r9 — The response correctly predicts that the slope will be cut in half when the mass doubles.
1/1r10 — The justification gives both an energy argument and a direct link to where m appears in the slope expression, so either one alone would have earned the point.
Finding the spring constant of a toy launcher · mid-scoring response5/10

(a) First measure the mass of the ball with the balance, then push the spring down and measure how far it went down with the ruler. Let the ball go and see how high it goes using the meterstick, and do this for 5 different compressions so there is enough data to make a graph.

(b) Graph h vs x² because energy is conserved, so mgh = kx², which means h = (k/mg)x². This is like y = mx, so the graph will be a straight line. The x² values are 0.0004, 0.0009, 0.0016, 0.0025 and 0.0036.

(c) [Graph: x² (m²) on the horizontal axis from 0 to 0.004, h (m) on the vertical axis from 0 to 0.8, both evenly scaled. Five points plotted correctly. A straight best-fit line is drawn with points on both sides.]

(d) From my line I picked the points (0.0005, 0.09) and (0.0035, 0.67). Slope = (0.67 − 0.09)/(0.0035 − 0.0005) = 0.58/0.003 = 193. Since slope = k/mg, k = slope × mg = 193 × 0.050 × 10 = 97 N/m.

(e) The slope stays the same, because the slope tells you the spring constant and it is the same spring, so k doesn't change.

How it scored

1/1r1 — The response names the quantities and an instrument for each one: x with the ruler, h with the meterstick, and m with the balance.
0/1r2 — The phrase "see how high it goes" gives no real method. It never says where h is measured from or how anyone could judge the peak, since the whole flight lasts well under a second and the ball sits at its highest point only briefly. The slow-motion camera on the equipment list goes unused.
0/1r3 — Five compressions give a reasonable range, but there is only one launch at each, with no averaging and no other step that would reduce the uncertainty in h.
1/1r4 — Graphing h versus x² is the correct choice, and the values are recorded. The missing ½ in the energy reasoning is penalized later in the rubric, not on this line.
1/1r5 — The axes are labeled, evenly scaled and carry units, and all five points are plotted accurately.
1/1r6 — The student draws a single straight line that balances the points on both sides.
0/1r7 — The energy stored in a spring is ½kx², not kx². Dropping the ½ makes the slope k/(mg) instead of k/(2mg), so the stated relationship between slope and spring constant is wrong.
1/1r8 — The slope is read from points on the drawn line, and 97 N/m follows correctly from the student's own slope relationship, with units. Readers credit this as consistent with the earlier error rather than penalizing the same mistake twice.
0/1r9 — The prediction is wrong, because the slope is not k itself but k divided by 2mg, so it changes whenever m changes.
0/1r10 — The reasoning confuses the slope with the spring constant. It is true that k stays the same, but the student never connects the slope to the mass of the ball, which is the whole point of the question.
Measuring the rotational inertia of a lab flywheel · high-scoring response9/10

(a) Measure each hanging mass on the balance. Wind the string around the hub the same way every time so that R stays 5.0 cm. Hold the block still so that it starts from rest, with its bottom exactly 1.00 m above the floor as measured with the meterstick. Start the stopwatch when I let go and stop it when the block hits the floor. Since the block starts from rest and has constant acceleration, D = ½at², so a = 2D/t² with D = 1.00 m. Use the masses 0.20, 0.25, 0.40, 0.50 and 1.00 kg.

(b) Flipping the given equation gives 1/a = (m + I/R²)/(mg) = 1/g + (I/(gR²))(1/m), so I will graph 1/a on the vertical axis and 1/m on the horizontal axis, and the slope will be I/(gR²). 1/m (kg⁻¹): 5.0, 4.0, 2.5, 2.0, 1.0 1/a (s²/m): 1.14, 0.93, 0.61, 0.51, 0.31

(c) [Graph: horizontal axis 1/m (kg⁻¹) from 0 to 6 in steps of 1. Vertical axis 1/a (s²/m) from 0 to 1.4 in steps of 0.2. All five points are plotted, and a straight line is drawn through them, crossing the vertical axis at about 0.10.]

(d) Points on my line: (1.5, 0.41) and (4.5, 1.03). Slope = (1.03 − 0.41)/(4.5 − 1.5) = 0.62/3.0 = 0.207 kg·s²/m. Since slope = I/(gR²), I = slope × g × R² = 0.207 × 10 × (0.050 m)² = 0.0052 kg·m².

(e) The intercept should be 1/g = 0.10 s²/m. The intercept is where 1/m = 0, which means a hanging mass so big that I/R² is tiny compared with it. Then the disk barely holds the block back and the block falls almost freely, so a gets close to g. My line crosses the vertical axis at about 0.10 s²/m, so the graph supports the equation.

How it scored

1/1r1 — The response names the mass (measured on the balance), the fall distance (measured with the meterstick) and the fall time (measured with the stopwatch).
1/1r2 — It releases the block from rest, fixes D at 1.00 m and converts each time with a = 2D/t², which is valid only because the block starts from rest. Winding the string on the hub the same way each time keeps R constant.
0/1r3 — Five masses give a good range, but every mass is timed only once. Hand timing a 1 m drop carries large reaction-time error, and the response includes no repeated trials or averages to reduce it.
1/1r4 — Graphing 1/a versus 1/m is correctly derived from the given relationship, and the calculated values are recorded.
1/1r5 — Both axes are labeled with units on even scales, and the points are plotted accurately.
1/1r6 — There is one straight line that balances the points, with its intercept left wherever the data put it.
1/1r7 — The response correctly states that the slope equals I/(gR²).
1/1r8 — The slope is taken from points on the drawn line, and R is converted to 0.050 m before squaring, giving I = 0.0052 kg·m² with correct units.
1/1r9 — The response correctly predicts an intercept of 1/g, which is 0.10 s²/m.
1/1r10 — The justification explains what 1/m = 0 means physically, describes the limit in which a approaches g, and then checks that prediction against the graph.
Measuring the rotational inertia of a lab flywheel · mid-scoring response6/10

(a) Weigh the masses on the balance, then hang one mass on the string, hold it still and let go. Measure the height it falls with the meterstick and use the stopwatch to time how long it takes to hit the floor, and then a = 2d/t². Do 3 trials for each mass and average the times, and use 5 different masses.

(b) Graph 1/a vs 1/m, because 1/a = 1/g + (I/gR²)(1/m), which is the equation of a straight line. 1/m: 5, 4, 2.5, 2, 1 1/a: 1.14, 0.93, 0.61, 0.51, 0.31

(c) [Graph: horizontal axis 1/m (kg⁻¹) from 0 to 6, vertical axis 1/a (s²/m) from 0 to 1.4, both evenly scaled. Five points plotted correctly. A straight line is drawn from the origin up to (5, 1.2).]

(d) Slope = 1.2/5 = 0.24. Since slope = I/(gR²), I = slope × g × R² = 0.24 × 10 × 5.0² = 60 kg·m².

(e) The intercept should be 0, because if there is no hanging mass there is nothing pulling the string, so there is no acceleration. That's why my line goes through the origin.

How it scored

1/1r1 — The response names the mass, the fall height and the fall time, with an instrument for each one.
1/1r2 — It holds the block still before release, so a = 2d/t² is valid, and it explains how the raw readings of distance and time become the acceleration.
1/1r3 — Three trials per mass, averaged, across five different masses is enough to earn the uncertainty point.
1/1r4 — Graphing 1/a versus 1/m is correct, and the calculated values are recorded.
1/1r5 — The axes are labeled, evenly scaled and carry units, and the points are plotted accurately.
0/1r6 — The line is forced through the origin even though the data do not support that. Every point sits above it at small values of 1/m, so it does not balance the scatter.
1/1r7 — The response correctly states that the slope equals I/(gR²).
0/1r8 — R is left in centimeters, so the result is too large by a factor of 10,000, and the slope has no units either. A rotational inertia of 60 kg·m² for a small lab disk should have been a warning sign.
0/1r9 — The response predicts an intercept of zero instead of 1/g, which is 0.10 s²/m.
0/1r10 — The student confuses 1/m = 0 with m = 0. The intercept describes the limit of a very large hanging mass, where the block falls almost freely, not the limit of no mass at all.

Where points die

Writing a procedure that names the quantity but not the method, such as "measure how high the ball goes with a meterstick." Say where every measurement starts, what you hold constant, and how you read the position of a moving object. For a launched ball, measure h from the release position and locate the peak frame by frame on slow-motion video. If a raw reading needs converting before you graph it, write the conversion, such as a = 2D/t² for a block released from rest.

Doing one trial at each setting and calling the data good. Repeat each setting at least three times and average the results, and spread the independent variable over five or more values. Hand timing carries about 0.1–0.2 s of reaction-time error, so a longer drop distance or a motion detector also reduces uncertainty. Name the step you take, because readers will not assume it.

Graphing the raw variables, such as h versus x or a versus m, when the physics says the relationship is not linear. Start from the governing equation and rearrange it into the form y = (slope)x + intercept, so that the target quantity ends up inside the slope or the intercept. For example, ½kx² = mgh gives h versus x², and a = mg/(m + I/R²) inverts to give 1/a versus 1/m.

Connecting the dots, forcing the line through the origin, or taking the slope from two data rows that your line does not pass through. Draw one straight line with points scattered on both sides, and let it cross the axis wherever the data put it. Then pick two points on your line, far apart, to calculate the slope, using a data point only if your line actually runs through it. A nonzero intercept often represents real physics, like the 1/g intercept on a graph of 1/a versus 1/m.

Treating the slope as if it were the target quantity, for example saying the slope is the spring constant, so it cannot change when the ball's mass changes. Write the slope expression out in full, such as k/(2mg) or I/(gR²), and solve it for the target quantity. Any change to a quantity in that expression changes the slope, even when k or I stays the same. Check your units, and convert centimeters to meters before you square R.

Assuming the string tension equals the hanging weight mg while the block is falling, or treating any setup that is not moving fast as being in equilibrium. Tension equals mg only when the block has zero acceleration. A block speeding up as it falls has T < mg, because the net force mg − T is what accelerates it, and that difference is the reason the disk's rotational inertia affects the block's acceleration at all.

Score your own response

0 / 10

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.