A cannon on a cliff fires a projectile horizontally. Simultaneously, a second projectile is dropped straight down from the same height. Ignoring air resistance, which statement correctly compares the two projectiles?
- ABoth hit the ground at the same time, since each starts with zero vertical velocity and falls the same height under the same downward acceleration g.Correct
- BThe fired projectile hits first, because its horizontal velocity adds to the downward acceleration and increases its rate of vertical fall.
- CThe fired projectile hits later, because energy spent on horizontal motion reduces the vertical descent and lengthens its time of fall.
- DThe dropped projectile hits first, because moving straight down with no horizontal displacement gives it the shortest path to the ground.
Why A is right
This is a classic demonstration of the independence of horizontal and vertical motions in projectile physics. Both projectiles start at the same height with zero initial vertical velocity. Both experience the same downward gravitational acceleration g. Therefore, they take the same time to reach the ground. The fired projectile lands farther horizontally but at the same vertical arrival time. This principle is famously demonstrated with a 'monkey and hunter' experiment.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect. Horizontal velocity does not contribute to vertical acceleration; the two components of motion are independent with no air resistance, so the horizontal speed cannot increase the rate of fall.
- C
- Incorrect. No energy is 'transferred' between dimensions to slow the descent. Horizontal and vertical motion are independent, so horizontal motion neither impedes nor lengthens the vertical fall.
- D
- Incorrect. The straight-down path is shorter in length, but fall time depends only on initial vertical velocity and g, both identical here; horizontal displacement is irrelevant to the time of fall.