Does sleep after learning strengthen memory?
Question: Using the sources below, develop and justify an argument about whether sleeping after learning improves memory.
The three sources are fictional studies written for practice.
SOURCE 1 Introduction: Researchers tested whether a night of sleep protects newly learned material. Participants: 60 university students in the Netherlands, ages 18 to 24, recruited with campus flyers. All of them reported normal sleep and no sleep disorders. Method: At 9 p.m., each participant studied 40 pairs of unrelated words, such as cloud and hammer. They kept studying until they could recall at least 32 of the 40 pairs, and participants were then randomly assigned to one of two groups. The sleep group slept in the lab while EEG recorded their sleep stages. The wake group stayed awake in the lab all night, supervised, watching films. Both groups slept normally at home the next night. At 9 p.m. two days after learning (48 hours later), each participant saw the first word of each pair and had to recall the second. Results: The sleep group recalled an average of 30 of 40 pairs, while the wake group recalled an average of 23. The difference was statistically significant (p < .01). In the sleep group, minutes spent in slow-wave sleep (NREM stage 3) were positively correlated with recall (r = +.45). Discussion: The authors concluded that the first night of sleep after learning helps stabilize new memories. A later night of recovery sleep did not make up the loss.
SOURCE 2 Introduction: Researchers asked whether teenagers who sleep more learn new words better. Participants: 418 students, ages 13 to 17, at two public high schools in Australia. Parents gave consent and students agreed to take part. Method: Students wore wrist activity monitors for 14 school nights. Average sleep was 6.9 hours a night, ranging from 5.1 to 9.0 hours. During the second week, students studied 30 unfamiliar vocabulary words on Monday morning and were tested on them Friday. Results: Average nightly sleep was positively correlated with Friday recall (r = +.34, p < .001). Students who averaged under 7 hours recalled an average of 15 of 30 words, while students who averaged 7 hours or more recalled 19. Students who slept less also reported more caffeine and more evening screen time. Discussion: The authors noted that their design could not rule out other factors that differ between short and long sleepers.
SOURCE 3 Introduction: Researchers tested whether a daytime nap improves a physical skill. Participants: 48 paid adult volunteers in Canada, ages 20 to 35. Method: At noon, every participant practiced typing a five-key finger sequence as fast and accurately as possible. Participants were randomly assigned to take a 90-minute nap in the lab, with EEG recording, or to rest awake for 90 minutes while watching a nature video. At 4 p.m., everyone was tested on the sequence again with no further practice. Results: The nap group typed the sequence 16 percent faster than at the end of training, while the rest group was 3 percent faster. The difference was statistically significant (p < .01). Among nappers, the number of sleep spindles recorded in NREM stage 2 correlated with improvement (r = +.52). Discussion: The authors concluded that sleep strengthens memory for skills, not only memory for facts.
- (A)State a specific, defensible claim, grounded in psychological science, that answers the question. [1 pt]
- (B(i))Support your claim with one specific piece of evidence from one of the sources. [1 pt]
- (B(ii))Explain how the evidence in B(i) supports your claim, using a psychological perspective, theory, concept or research finding from AP Psychology. [2 pts]
- (C(i))Support your claim with one specific piece of evidence from a source other than the one you used in B(i). [1 pt]
- (C(ii))Explain how the evidence in C(i) supports your claim, using a psychological perspective, theory, concept or research finding different from the one you used in B(ii). [2 pts]