Skip to content
AP Psychology · Biological Bases of Behavior

Critical thinking

Critical thinking appears in 4 reviewed AP Psychology questions and sits in Biological Bases of Behavior. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

Critical thinking is the habit of judging a claim by its evidence instead of accepting it because it sounds right. You ask what the evidence is, whether other explanations fit, and whether the conclusion goes further than the data.

Why it matters

Psychology tests everyday beliefs against data, and biology topics are full of myths, such as the idea that we use only 10% of our brains. Critical thinking is how you reject a claim that feels true but fails the evidence.

How the exam tests it

Stems give you a claim, such as "your senses show you reality exactly as it is," and ask which evidence best refutes it. The strongest answer combines several lines of data: visual illusions, cultural differences in perception, and the brain filling in missing information.

Don’t confuse it with

Critical thinking is not the same as cynicism, because rejecting every claim is as lazy as accepting every claim. The point is to weigh evidence, so a well-supported claim should still be accepted.

Critical thinking in real questions

Example 1Harder
A student argues that 'the senses give us direct, accurate access to reality.' A professor responds that this is incorrect. Which of the following arguments would best support the professor's position?
  1. APerceptual illusions, cultural differences in perception, and constructive processing show that sensory experience involves interpretation that can differ from realityCorrect
  2. BThe senses only provide access to a limited portion of the electromagnetic and mechanical spectrum, and this information is perfectly faithfully transmitted without distortion
  3. CBecause our senses evolved for survival, they represent the objectively correct view of reality needed for adaptive behavior
  4. DPeople with better sensory acuity perceive reality more accurately, so the senses do eventually give correct information to those with good sensory hardware

Why A is right

The professor's position (that the senses do NOT give direct, accurate access to reality) is supported by multiple lines of evidence: (1) Perceptual illusions (like the Muller-Lyer) show the brain misinterprets physical stimuli; (2) Cross-cultural research shows perception is influenced by learned cultural experience; (3) Constructive perception research shows the brain fills in information, makes inferences, and uses prior knowledge — creating a model of reality that may deviate from physical reality; (4) Our limited sensory range means we only access a small portion of physical reality. Perception is a construction, not a readout.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because this actually supports the professor's position (senses access only a limited spectrum), but the claim that information is 'perfectly faithfully transmitted without distortion' is incorrect; neural transduction and processing do involve significant transformations and interpretations of the physical stimulus.
C
Incorrect because evolutionary fitness (survival advantage) does not guarantee perceptual accuracy; our senses are calibrated for survival-relevant information processing, not for accessing 'objective reality'; many perceptual biases and illusions exist because they are adaptive simplifications, not because they accurately mirror physical reality.
D
Incorrect because even individuals with perfect sensory acuity experience perceptual illusions and misinterpretations; better hardware doesn't eliminate the constructive, interpretive nature of perception; all humans share the same basic perceptual illusions because they share the same neural processing architecture.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Biological Bases of Behavior.