A researcher wants to study how expectations affect pain sensation. She plans to apply an inert cream to participants' forearms, tell them it contains a powerful anesthetic, and then measure how much discomfort they report from a brief heat stimulus. Under APA ethical guidelines, which of the following must be true for her to use this deception?
- AReveal before the session that the cream is inert, because informed consent requires participants to know the true purpose of a study in advance
- BObtain written approval from each participant's personal physician in addition to approval from the institutional review board
- CPay participants extra money to compensate them for any distress the deception might cause
- DUse the deception only if the question cannot be studied without it and it poses no significant harm, then debrief participants afterwardCorrect
Why D is right
This is a research-ethics question about deception, set in a study of pain sensation. Here, expectations about an anesthetic may change how intense the heat stimulus feels. APA guidelines allow deception only when the research question cannot reasonably be answered without it, when it poses no significant risk of harm, and when participants are debriefed afterward. Debriefing means telling them the cream was inert, explaining why, and making sure they leave without lasting negative effects. Informed consent still applies: participants agree to the general procedures, including the heat stimulus, without being told the hypothesis.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because telling participants in advance that the cream is inert would remove the expectation being studied and make the research impossible. Informed consent requires disclosing the procedures and risks, not every detail of the hypothesis, and APA allows deception when its conditions are met.
- B
- Incorrect because APA guidelines require approval from an institutional review board and consent from participants (or a guardian for minors), not approval from a personal physician. A physician's sign-off is not part of the ethical requirements for deception.
- C
- Incorrect because paying for distress is not an APA requirement and cannot make a harmful deception acceptable. What protects participants is avoiding significant harm and debriefing them afterward.