Skip to content
AP Psychology · Development and Learning

Extinction

Extinction appears in 16 reviewed AP Psychology questions and sits in Development and Learning. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

Extinction is the weakening of a learned response when its support is removed. In classical conditioning, the CS is presented again and again without the UCS. In operant conditioning, the behavior stops being reinforced.

Why it matters

Extinction shows that learned responses can fade, which is the basis of exposure therapy. It also shows the old learning is suppressed, not erased, because the response can return later.

How the exam tests it

Stems often describe a sequence: pairings build a fear, CS-alone trials bring it to zero, and after a rest the response briefly returns. You must label the phases acquisition, extinction, and spontaneous recovery.

Don’t confuse it with

Students confuse extinction with forgetting or with punishment, but extinction comes from removing the reinforcer or UCS, not from time passing or from adding a bad consequence.

Extinction in real questions

Example 1Medium
When a child's behavior of throwing tantrums in stores is no longer reinforced by parental attention, the parent notices that the tantrums briefly become more intense and frequent before finally stopping. This initial worsening of behavior when reinforcement is removed is known as:
  1. ASpontaneous recovery, because the tantrum behavior reemerged after a period without reinforcement
  2. BNegative punishment, because the parent removed attention (a positive stimulus) contingent on the tantrum behavior
  3. CExtinction burst, because an organism initially increases the rate or intensity of a behavior when reinforcement is first removedCorrect
  4. DPositive punishment, because the parent's withdrawal of attention acts as an aversive stimulus that intensifies the child's distress

Why C is right

An extinction burst refers to the temporary increase in the frequency, intensity, or variability of a behavior when reinforcement is first withheld. When the tantrum behavior stops working (no longer produces parental attention), the child 'tries harder' before the behavior eventually extinguishes. Understanding extinction bursts is crucial in applied behavior analysis, as caregivers may mistakenly reinstate attention during the burst, which strengthens the behavior.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because spontaneous recovery refers to the reappearance of an extinguished behavior after a rest period, not to an increase in the behavior during the initial phase of extinction when reinforcement is first removed.
B
Incorrect because negative punishment involves deliberately removing a pleasant stimulus to decrease a behavior. While the parent is withdrawing attention, the question asks specifically about the temporary increase in tantrum behavior, which is the extinction burst phenomenon, not punishment.
D
Incorrect because positive punishment involves adding an aversive stimulus to decrease a behavior. The parent is not adding anything aversive — they are simply withholding reinforcement, which causes the extinction burst rather than constituting punishment.
Example 2Medium
A researcher pairs a light with a loud noise 40 times. After establishing a strong conditioned fear response to the light, the researcher now presents the light 50 times alone, without the noise. Responding decreases to zero. Two days later the light is presented again and a weak fear response reoccurs. This sequence of events demonstrates:
  1. AAcquisition, stimulus discrimination, and reconditioning
  2. BFlooding, response prevention, and symptom substitution
  3. CGeneralization, discrimination, and counter-conditioning
  4. DAcquisition, extinction, and spontaneous recoveryCorrect

Why D is right

The three phases described correspond exactly to: (1) Acquisition — fear response built up through CS-UCS pairings; (2) Extinction — CR eliminated through repeated CS-alone presentations; (3) Spontaneous recovery — the CR reappears after a rest period without additional conditioning, demonstrating that extinction does not permanently erase the original association.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Stimulus discrimination involves learning to respond only to the specific CS; the reappearance of responding after rest is spontaneous recovery, not reconditioning.
B
Flooding is an exposure therapy technique; response prevention is used for OCD; symptom substitution is a psychoanalytic concept. None of these apply to the described classical conditioning sequence.
C
Generalization involves responding to similar stimuli; discrimination involves responding selectively; counter-conditioning pairs the CS with an incompatible response. None of these describe the sequence presented.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Development and Learning.