The 'minimal group paradigm' (Tajfel) demonstrated that in-group favoritism arises:
Why A is right
Henri Tajfel's minimal group paradigm studies assigned participants to groups based on trivial, arbitrary criteria (e.g., whether they underestimated or overestimated the number of dots, or which of two abstract paintings they preferred). Despite having no shared history, no interaction with group members, and no rational reason for group loyalty, participants consistently allocated more resources to in-group members and fewer to out-group members. This demonstrated that mere categorization alone is sufficient to produce in-group favoritism.