A person is given a drug that blocks beta-adrenergic receptors (beta blockers) before giving a public speech. The drug reduces their heart rate and prevents some physical symptoms of anxiety. Based on the James-Lange theory of emotion, what effect might this have on the person's experienced fear?
- ADelayed fear, because the drug prevents immediate emotional experience but the fear will emerge unchanged once the drug wears off
- BNo effect, because emotional experience is generated entirely by the brain and is not influenced by peripheral physiological signals
- CReduced fear, because according to James-Lange theory, we feel emotions partly because we notice our physiological reactions, so reducing those reactions reduces the emotionCorrect
- DIncreased fear, because blocking beta receptors activates the parasympathetic system, which generates fear responses in the absence of threat
Why C is right
The James-Lange theory holds that emotions arise from our perception of our own physiological responses to stimuli: we feel afraid because we notice our heart racing, hands trembling, and breathing fast. If a beta-blocker reduces these peripheral physiological symptoms (heart rate, trembling), then according to this theory, the subjective experience of fear should also be reduced because there is less physiological evidence for the brain to interpret as 'I am afraid.' Research does suggest performance anxiety can be reduced by beta-blockers in some contexts.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the James-Lange theory predicts that the emotion and the physiological state co-occur in real time; the theory would not predict that emotion is simply delayed while the drug is active and returns unchanged when it wears off.
- B
- Incorrect because this contradicts the James-Lange theory; the theory specifically posits that peripheral physiological responses are the source of emotional experience, not just an accompaniment to it; James-Lange would predict that reducing physical symptoms should affect the emotional experience.
- D
- Incorrect because beta-blockers (which block sympathetic adrenergic receptors) do not directly activate the parasympathetic system; while relative parasympathetic tone may increase as sympathetic activity decreases, this does not generate fear responses; fear is associated with sympathetic arousal.