Skip to content
AP Psychology · Social Psychology and Personality

Psychoanalysis criticism

Psychoanalysis criticism appears in 3 reviewed AP Psychology questions and sits in Social Psychology and Personality. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

The main scientific criticism of psychoanalysis is that it is unfalsifiable. It can explain a behavior and its exact opposite, so no result could ever prove it wrong.

Why it matters

Science depends on theories that make risky predictions that could fail. Freud also built his theory on a small, unrepresentative set of case studies, largely of upper-middle-class Viennese patients. He reconstructed his case reports after the sessions, and no one checked them independently.

How the exam tests it

Questions ask which statement best shows a scientific criticism of Freud. Look for the answer about unfalsifiability: if a patient improves, the theory is confirmed, and if not, it is called resistance, so the theory always wins.

Don’t confuse it with

Students think the criticism means the unconscious does not exist, but modern research does support unconscious processing; the problem is that Freud's specific claims cannot be tested.

Psychoanalysis criticism in real questions

Example 1Harder
Which of the following BEST illustrates a criticism of psychoanalytic theory from a scientific perspective?
  1. AFreud's theory is unfalsifiable because it can explain a behavior and its opposite, so no finding could ever disconfirm itCorrect
  2. BPsychoanalysis overemphasizes the role of learning and conditioning in personality development
  3. CFreud's theory is too deterministic in its emphasis on free will and conscious choice as shapers of behavior
  4. DPsychoanalysis is impractical because therapy sessions are too expensive and time-consuming for most patients, which limits who can benefit from it

Why A is right

The most fundamental scientific criticism of psychoanalytic theory is that it is unfalsifiable. If a patient improves in therapy, it confirms the theory. If they don't, it is 'resistance.' If someone is sexually inhibited, it reflects repression; if sexually expressive, it reflects fixation. Because the theory accommodates any outcome, no finding can decisively disconfirm it.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because psychoanalysis underemphasizes (not overemphasizes) learning and conditioning; the behavioral perspective, not psychoanalysis, emphasizes conditioning.
C
Incorrect because psychoanalysis is criticized for being too deterministic (unconscious forces determine behavior) and ignoring free will, not for overemphasizing it.
D
Incorrect because the cost and length of therapy are practical concerns about treatment delivery, not scientific criticisms of the theory's validity or falsifiability.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Social Psychology and Personality.