Skip to content
AP Psychology · Biological Bases of Behavior

Response criterion

Response criterion appears in 4 reviewed AP Psychology questions and sits in Biological Bases of Behavior. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

In signal detection theory, the response criterion is how much evidence you need before you say "yes, I detected it." It depends on your motivation, your expectations and the costs of a miss versus a false alarm.

Why it matters

It explains why the same faint stimulus is reported in one situation and missed in another, even when your senses have not changed. A worried parent listening for a baby sets a low, liberal criterion, so they get more hits but also more false alarms.

How the exam tests it

Stems give a scenario, such as a radar operator in wartime or a doctor scanning X-rays, and ask why detection changed. If the cause is motivation or payoff rather than signal strength, the answer is the criterion.

Don’t confuse it with

Students confuse it with sensitivity, which is how well you can tell signal from noise; the criterion is a decision about when to say yes, not a measure of how sharp your senses are.

Response criterion in real questions

Example 1Medium
Signal detection theory (SDT) argues that detecting a stimulus is not simply about the stimulus exceeding a fixed threshold. Which of the following BEST captures the central insight of SDT?
  1. ADetection depends on the ratio of signal to noise in the physical environment, which is fixed independently of the observer's psychology
  2. BDetection depends on signal strength relative to background noise and on the observer's decision criterionCorrect
  3. CDetection depends only on stimulus intensity; once intensity exceeds an absolute threshold, the observer will always detect the signal
  4. DDetection is primarily determined by the observer's prior expectations and has little to do with actual stimulus presence

Why B is right

Signal detection theory proposes that stimulus detection involves two components: (1) sensitivity (d' — how well the observer can discriminate the signal from background noise, based on signal strength and sensory acuity) and (2) the response criterion (beta — how willing the observer is to say 'yes, I detected it,' based on motivation, expectation, and the costs of false alarms vs. misses). This is why the same physical signal can be detected in some conditions and missed in others.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because SDT specifically argues that detection is NOT fixed by physics alone; the observer's psychological criterion (bias) plays a crucial role alongside physical signal-to-noise ratio; removing observer psychology from the model is exactly what SDT was designed to avoid.
C
Incorrect because this describes the classic threshold model that SDT was developed to replace; SDT rejects the idea of a fixed threshold that automatically triggers detection; instead, it recognizes that observer bias (criterion) affects detection decisions.
D
Incorrect because while prior expectations DO influence the criterion in SDT, they do not make sensitivity (d') irrelevant; both signal strength and decision criterion jointly determine detection outcomes; SDT incorporates both, not prior expectations alone.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Biological Bases of Behavior.