A researcher studying memory retrieval e-mails a one-time online survey to 1,000 adults asking how often they experience the tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon, in which a known word temporarily cannot be retrieved. Only 200 people complete it, and those who do report far more frequent tip-of-the-tongue lapses than is typical. Which type of bias is MOST illustrated here?
- AAttrition bias, because a large share of participants dropped out over the course of a longitudinal memory study
- BSocial desirability bias, because respondents wanted to appear to have better memories than they actually do
- CObserver bias, because the researcher's expectations about memory lapses influenced which participants chose to respond
- DSelf-selection bias, because the people who chose to respond likely differ in how often they have memory lapsesCorrect
Why D is right
This is self-selection (volunteer) bias: when participants decide for themselves whether to take part, those who volunteer can differ systematically from those who do not. People who often have tip-of-the-tongue experiences, a retrieval failure studied in the memory topics of Unit 2 (Cognition), are likely more interested in a survey about them, so the 200 respondents overrepresent frequent sufferers. The results therefore cannot be generalized to the whole population of 1,000 adults, much less to adults in general.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because attrition bias involves participants dropping out partway through a study that follows them over time; this was a single, one-time survey, and the problem is who chose to respond at all, not who quit later.
- B
- Incorrect because social desirability bias would push respondents to under-report memory lapses to look capable; here respondents reported unusually many lapses, and the issue is who responded, not how they slanted their answers.
- C
- Incorrect because observer bias occurs when a researcher's expectations distort how data are recorded or interpreted; the researcher did not choose the respondents, the respondents chose themselves.
A researcher studying PTSD treatment compares veterans who chose to attend group therapy (n = 40) versus those who did not attend (n = 40) and finds that the therapy group has significantly lower PTSD symptoms. What is the primary reason the researcher CANNOT conclude that therapy reduced PTSD symptoms?
- APTSD symptoms are subjective and cannot be meaningfully measured with the standardized instruments researchers typically use
- BThe study lacks a placebo condition, so any improvement could be attributed to general attention rather than the therapy
- CThe sample size is too small to detect significant differences between groups
- DWithout random assignment, the groups may have differed at the start; those who chose therapy may be more motivatedCorrect
Why D is right
Without random assignment, this is a quasi-experimental study. Veterans who chose therapy may be more motivated to improve, less severely affected, or more socially supported — all of which could explain lower PTSD symptoms independent of therapy. Pre-existing group differences (self-selection confound) prevent causal conclusions.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because PTSD symptoms can be reliably measured using validated standardized scales (e.g., PCL-5); measurement validity is not the primary limitation here.
- B
- Incorrect because a placebo condition addresses expectancy effects; the more fundamental problem is that groups self-selected, creating pre-existing differences that confound the comparison.
- C
- Incorrect because n = 40 per group is a reasonable sample size for detecting moderate effects; the primary limitation is the absence of random assignment, not sample size.