Skip to content
AP Psychology · Social Psychology and Personality

Steele

Steele appears in 3 reviewed AP Psychology questions and sits in Social Psychology and Personality. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

Claude Steele is the social psychologist who, with Joshua Aronson in 1995, identified stereotype threat. Stereotype threat is when fear of confirming a negative stereotype about your group creates anxiety that lowers your performance.

Why it matters

His work shows that test score gaps can come partly from the testing situation, not just ability. In his studies, Black students did worse on a hard verbal test when told it measured intellectual ability, but performed better when the same test was described as a simple lab task.

How the exam tests it

Questions ask what Steele found. The right answer says stereotype awareness can hurt performance through anxiety and mental load, and the effect hits hardest in strong students who care about doing well.

Don’t confuse it with

A self-fulfilling prophecy is any belief or expectation, held by others or by you, that leads to behavior that makes it come true. A teacher's high expectations raising a student's grades is one example. Stereotype threat is narrower, because it is the in-the-moment anxiety of possibly confirming a negative stereotype about your group, which lowers performance.

Steele in real questions

Example 1Medium
Claude Steele's research on 'stereotype threat' found that:
  1. AStereotypes about group ability directly impair test performance only in groups with genuinely lower average ability
  2. BStereotypes consistently improve performance in groups stereotyped as highly intelligent or capable
  3. CStereotype threat effects disappear when individuals are reminded of their individual identity rather than group identity
  4. DAwareness of a negative stereotype about one's group can undermine test performance through anxiety and cognitive disruptionCorrect

Why D is right

Steele and Aronson's stereotype threat research demonstrated that when individuals are aware of a negative stereotype about their group's ability and fear confirming that stereotype, the resulting anxiety and cognitive load impairs performance on challenging tests. For example, Black students performed worse on a difficult verbal test when it was framed as a test of intellectual ability than when framed as a non-diagnostic laboratory task. Importantly, the effect occurs in high-performing group members who care about the domain.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because stereotype threat specifically demonstrates that performance impairment can occur due to social-psychological mechanisms independent of actual ability differences; the effect shows group ability stereotypes can become self-fulfilling.
B
Incorrect because stereotype threat is specifically about negative stereotypes undermining performance; positive stereotypes can sometimes boost performance ('stereotype lift') but this is not Steele's central finding.
C
Incorrect because affirming an alternative identity can reduce stereotype threat, but the research shows threat is not automatically eliminated by individual identification; this partially describes affirmation interventions that reduce (but may not eliminate) stereotype threat.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Social Psychology and Personality.