A rare disease affects 1 in 5,000 people. A medical test for the disease has a 99% true positive rate (sensitivity) and a 98% true negative rate (specificity). If a randomly selected person tests positive, what is the approximate probability that the person actually has the disease?
- AApproximately 99%, because the test has 99% sensitivity
- BApproximately 50%, because either the person has it or does not
- CApproximately 98%, because the test has 98% specificity
- DApproximately 0.5%, because the disease is rare and most positives are false positivesCorrect
Why D is right
Using Bayes' theorem: P(disease | positive) = P(positive | disease) * P(disease) / P(positive). P(disease) = 1/5000 = 0.0002. P(positive | disease) = 0.99. P(positive | no disease) = 0.02. P(positive) = 0.99(0.0002) + 0.02(0.9998) = 0.000198 + 0.019996 = 0.020194. P(disease | positive) = 0.000198/0.020194 ≈ 0.0098, or about 1%. Even with a very accurate test, the extreme rarity of the disease means most positive results are false positives.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. The 99% sensitivity describes the test's ability to detect the disease when present, not the probability of having the disease given a positive test. When the disease is rare, these are very different quantities.
- B
- Incorrect. The probability is not 50/50. The base rate (prevalence) of the disease strongly influences the posterior probability through Bayes' theorem.
- C
- Incorrect. The 98% specificity means 98% of healthy people test negative, but the 2% who test positive vastly outnumber the true positives because healthy people far outnumber sick people.