A factory produces light bulbs. The probability that any single bulb is defective is 0.02. A random sample of 200 bulbs is tested. For the normal approximation to the binomial, are the conditions met?
- AYes: np = 200(0.02) = 4 ≥ 10 is satisfied.
- BNo: p = 0.02 is too small for any approximation.
- CNo: np = 4 < 10, so the conditions are not satisfied.Correct
- DYes: n > 30 is sufficient for normal approximation.
Why C is right
The conditions for the normal approximation to the binomial are np ≥ 10 AND n(1-p) ≥ 10. Here: np = 200(0.02) = 4 < 10. Although n(1-p) = 200(0.98) = 196 ≥ 10, both conditions must be met. Since np = 4 < 10, the normal approximation should NOT be used. A Poisson approximation would be more appropriate here.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- np = 4 does NOT satisfy the condition np ≥ 10. The condition is ≥ 10, not ≥ 1.
- B
- Small values of p are problematic for normal approximation, but Poisson approximation works well for small p and large n. The problem is np < 10, not that no approximation exists.
- D
- n > 30 is the condition for the Central Limit Theorem approximating sample means, not for the binomial-to-normal approximation. The binomial approximation requires np ≥ 10 and n(1-p) ≥ 10.
Which of the following conditions must be verified before performing a one-proportion z-test?
- AThe sample proportion equals the hypothesized proportion and the sample is large
- BThe data are collected from a random sample and both np0 and n(1 - p0) are at least 10Correct
- CThe population standard deviation is known and the sample size is at least 30
- DThe population is normally distributed and the sample is collected with replacement
Why B is right
The conditions for a one-proportion z-test require: (1) a random sample or random assignment, (2) the Large Counts condition that np0 >= 10 and n(1 - p0) >= 10, and (3) the 10% condition if sampling without replacement. Choice A captures the two most essential conditions.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the sample proportion does not need to equal the hypothesized proportion; in fact, the test is designed to assess whether they differ significantly.
- C
- Incorrect because one-proportion z-tests do not involve population standard deviations (those pertain to z-tests for means), and the sample size threshold of 30 is a rule of thumb for the Central Limit Theorem with means, not proportions.
- D
- Incorrect because the test does not require the population to be normally distributed; the sampling distribution of p-hat is approximately normal when the Large Counts condition is met. Sampling with replacement is not a standard requirement.
A high school has 2,000 students. The student council wants to estimate p, the proportion of all students at the school who support a later start time. Two data collection plans are proposed.
Plan I: Select a simple random sample of 150 students from the school roster and ask each selected student the question.
Plan II: Post the question on the school website and use the first 400 students who respond.
The sample proportion p-hat from each plan will be used to estimate p. Which plan should the council use, and why?
- APlan I, because 400 is more than 10% of the 2,000 students, and that makes the p-hat from Plan II a biased estimator of p.
- BPlan I, because random selection makes p-hat an unbiased estimator of p; Plan II has less variability but is likely biased by voluntary response.Correct
- CNeither plan, because p-hat is an unbiased estimator of p only after the large counts condition is checked.
- DPlan II, because with 400 responses p-hat varies less from sample to sample, so it will be closer to p than Plan I.
Why B is right
p-hat is an unbiased estimator of p, meaning the center of its sampling distribution equals p, only when the data come from a random sample. Plan I meets that condition. Plan II is a voluntary response sample: students with strong opinions are more likely to respond, so its p-hat may be systematically too high or too low. Plan II's larger sample does lower the variability of p-hat, but a larger sample does not remove bias, so Plan I gives the better estimator.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Misuses the 10% condition. 400/2000 = 20% does break that condition, but the condition only controls whether the formula sqrt(p(1-p)/n) is accurate for the standard deviation. Sampling more than 10% does not make p-hat biased. Plan II's bias comes from voluntary response.
- C
- Mixes up the conditions: large counts (np >= 10 and n(1-p) >= 10) decides whether the sampling distribution is approximately normal. It has nothing to do with whether p-hat is unbiased, which depends on random sampling.
- D
- Mixes up variability with bias: a larger sample makes p-hat vary less, but a precise estimate from a biased method still centers on the wrong value, so being less variable does not mean it is closer to p.