A student wants to test whether the mean commute time in her city differs from the national average of 26 minutes. She collects a random sample of 16 commuters and finds a sample mean of 29 minutes and a sample standard deviation of 8 minutes. Before conducting a t-test, she checks conditions. The sample data show a strong right skew with one extreme outlier. What should she do?
- ABe cautious about the t-test, since with n = 16 it is not robust to strong skewness and outliers; consider a nonparametric test or a larger sampleCorrect
- BProceed with the t-test because the sample size of 16 is large enough
- CIncrease the significance level to alpha = 0.10 to account for the skewness
- DRemove the outlier and proceed with the t-test on the remaining 15 observations, since without the extreme value the remaining data can be treated as approximately normal
Why A is right
With n = 16, the t-test is not robust to severe departures from normality. Strong right skew with an extreme outlier violates the normality condition and cannot be overcome by a sample size this small. The researcher should either collect a larger sample (so the CLT provides approximate normality), use a nonparametric test, or investigate the outlier.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because n = 16 is not large enough for the CLT to compensate for strong skewness and outliers; larger samples (n >= 30-40) are needed.
- C
- Incorrect because changing alpha does not address the violation of the normality condition; it only changes the decision threshold.
- D
- Incorrect because removing an outlier without justification (such as a data entry error) can bias the results and is not recommended practice; moreover, the strong right skew remains even after the outlier is dropped, so the data still cannot be treated as approximately normal.