A set of data shows a strong negative association between the number of firefighters sent to a fire and the amount of property damage (in dollars). A student concludes that sending more firefighters causes more property damage. What is the most likely explanation for this association?
- AThe relationship is an example of extrapolation beyond the range of the data
- BThere is likely a confounding variable, the severity of the fire, associated with both the number of firefighters and the damageCorrect
- CThe correlation must be positive, not negative, so the student has misread the data
- DThe student's conclusion is correct because the data show a strong association between the number of firefighters and the amount of damage
Why B is right
The severity of the fire is a confounding (lurking) variable. Larger, more severe fires require more firefighters AND cause more property damage. The association between firefighters and damage does not mean firefighters cause damage; both are driven by fire severity.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because extrapolation involves making predictions outside the observed range of data, which is not the issue here.
- C
- Incorrect because the problem states the association is strong and negative (more firefighters, more damage), which is plausible due to confounding — there is no reason to doubt the sign of the correlation.
- D
- Incorrect because a strong association does not establish causation, especially in an observational context where confounding variables likely exist.
A school district examines reading scores across 10 elementary schools. For each school, the percentage of students receiving free lunch and the mean reading score are recorded. The regression yields r-squared = 0.78. A district official states: "This proves that free lunch programs lower reading scores." Which of the following is the most valid criticism?
- ATen schools is always too few observations to perform regression
- BReading scores should be measured using the median, not the mean
- CThe r-squared value is not high enough to support any conclusion
- DThe analysis uses aggregated school-level data rather than individual student data, and the correlation between aggregated variables can overstate the individual-level relationshipCorrect
Why D is right
This is an example of the ecological fallacy — drawing conclusions about individuals from aggregated (group-level) data. Correlations using group averages tend to be higher than correlations at the individual level. Additionally, the free lunch percentage is a proxy for socioeconomic status, and causal language is inappropriate for an observational study.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because while 10 observations is small, regression can be performed with as few as 3 observations; the critical issues are the ecological fallacy and the causal claim.
- B
- Incorrect because the choice between mean and median is a secondary concern; the primary issue is the ecological fallacy and the inappropriate causal inference.
- C
- Incorrect because r-squared = 0.78 is actually quite high; the problem is the level of analysis and the causal claim, not the strength of the correlation.