The table shows hypothetical data on five federal laws, how each law involves the states, and how a federal court ruled on each law's constitutionality.
| Hypothetical federal law | How the law involves the states | Court outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Law 1 | Offers extra highway funds to states that adopt a lower speed limit | Upheld |
| Law 2 | Orders county sheriffs to run background checks on buyers under a federal gun law | Struck down |
| Law 3 | Requires state legislatures to pass federally designed waste-disposal regulations | Struck down |
| Law 4 | Has federal agents directly enforce a federal air-pollution standard | Upheld |
| Law 5 | Conditions federal education grants on states adopting testing standards | Upheld |
The pattern of court outcomes in the table is most consistent with which constitutional principle?
- AThe Supremacy Clause, under which valid federal law overrides any conflicting state law
- BThe Necessary and Proper Clause, which forbids Congress from attaching conditions to grants
- CThe Tenth Amendment, read to bar Congress from commandeering state governmentsCorrect
- DThe Ninth Amendment, which protects sovereign rights the states held before ratification
Why C is right
In the table, the two laws struck down (Laws 2 and 3) are the only ones that order state or local officials or legislatures to carry out a federal program. The laws that were upheld either offer states money with conditions attached (Laws 1 and 5) or have federal officials enforce federal law directly (Law 4). This pattern matches the anti-commandeering doctrine grounded in the Tenth Amendment, which reserves undelegated powers to the states. Under that doctrine, Congress may encourage states through conditional grants or act through its own agents, but it may not force state governments to administer federal programs. The Supreme Court applied this doctrine in New York v. United States (1992) and Printz v. United States (1997).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The Supremacy Clause favors federal authority over states; if it alone explained the outcomes, Laws 2 and 3 would have been upheld too. It cannot account for the two laws that were struck down.
- B
- The Necessary and Proper Clause expands Congress's implied powers rather than limiting grant conditions, and the table contradicts this choice: Laws 1 and 5, which attach conditions to federal funds, were both upheld.
- D
- The Ninth Amendment protects unenumerated rights retained by the people, not state sovereignty. It does not explain why laws directing state officials were struck down while incentive and direct-enforcement laws were upheld.
The constitutional principle articulated in Printz v. United States (1997) regarding federal commandeering of state officials holds that
- Astates may not 'commandeer' federal agencies to enforce state law, while the federal government stays free to direct state officials to implement mandates
- BCongress may commandeer state legislatures to enact implementing legislation for federal programs but may not direct state executive officials to administer them
- CCongress may not compel state executive officials to administer or enforce federal regulatory programs, an intrusion on reserved state sovereigntyCorrect
- Dthe Spending Clause lets Congress commandeer state officials outright by conditioning their receipt of federal funds on administrative cooperation
Why C is right
In Printz v. United States, the Court (5-4, Scalia majority) struck down the Brady Handgun Violence Prevention Act's requirement that state law enforcement officials conduct background checks on handgun purchasers. The Court held that the Tenth Amendment and the Constitution's design of dual sovereignty prohibit the federal government from 'commandeering' state executive officers to administer federal regulatory programs. The federal government must rely on its own executive officers or induce state cooperation through conditions on grants. This anti-commandeering principle was also applied to state legislatures in New York v. United States (1992).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Printz established precisely the opposite — the federal government may not commandeer state executive officials; the principle runs in one direction: limiting federal power over state officials, not state power over federal agencies.
- B
- Incorrect because both state legislatures and state executive officials are protected from commandeering; New York v. United States (1992) addressed legislative commandeering; Printz extended the principle to executive officers; Congress cannot commandeer either branch of state government.
- D
- Incorrect because the Spending Clause allows Congress to offer conditional grants (inducements), not to commandeer; the key distinction is between conditions on voluntary federal grants (permissible) and direct commands to state officials (impermissible under Printz).