The following practice passage describes two phone calls.
During a Senate race, a voter receives two phone calls in the same week.
Call 1: The caller says she is conducting a survey and asks a single question: Would you be more or less likely to vote for Candidate Rivera if you learned that she voted seventeen times to cut benefits for seniors? She asks nothing else, and the call ends in under a minute. Identical calls go out to tens of thousands of households.
Call 2: The caller asks which candidate the voter currently prefers, how firmly, and which issue matters most, then asks the voter's age, party, and county. The firm contacts about 900 randomly selected likely voters and reports a margin of error.
Based on the passage, which of the following most accurately compares the two calls?
- ACall 1 is likely to produce more accurate results than Call 2 because it reached tens of thousands more households overall
- BCall 2 is meant to spread negative information about a candidate, while Call 1 measures what voters already think
- CCall 1 is meant to change how voters view a candidate, while Call 2 is meant to measure voters' existing preferencesCorrect
- DCall 2 is less trustworthy than Call 1 because asking about party and age introduces bias
Why C is right
Call 1 in the passage is a push poll: it poses as a survey but asks one loaded question that plants damaging information about Candidate Rivera, collects no other data, and is sent to as many households as possible. Its purpose is to move opinion, not record it. Call 2 is a legitimate opinion poll: it asks neutral questions about current preferences and issue priorities, gathers demographic data for weighting, uses a random sample of likely voters, and reports a margin of error. So Call 1 tries to change views while Call 2 measures them.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Misreads the passage's numbers: reaching more households does not make Call 1 more accurate. Call 1 has no random sample and gathers almost no data, while Call 2's random sample of about 900 is enough for a valid poll with a reported margin of error.
- B
- Reverses the two calls. In the passage, Call 1 is the one that spreads a negative claim about Rivera; Call 2 asks neutral questions about current preferences.
- D
- Asking about age, party, and county, as Call 2 does, is standard practice in legitimate polls so results can be checked and weighted against the population; it does not introduce bias. The loaded wording is in Call 1.
The 'push poll' is a technique in political polling that is criticized because it:
- AConducts surveys through automated phone systems that cannot verify caller identity, leading to fraudulent responses from non-registered voters
- BUses loaded, leading questions to push respondents toward a predetermined answer, disguising negative campaigning as legitimate opinion pollingCorrect
- CReleases poll results before all precincts have reported on election night, potentially influencing the voting behavior of late voters on the West Coast
- DContacts only registered party members rather than all eligible voters, producing a skewed sample that fails to represent the full electorate
Why B is right
Push polls are not genuine polling but political communication disguised as research. They use loaded, leading questions — 'Would you be more or less likely to support Candidate X if you knew they had done Y?' — to implant negative information in respondents' minds while creating an appearance of legitimate polling. Professional pollsters condemn push polls as dishonest, but they are legal and difficult to regulate.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because robocall verification concerns are about data quality, not manipulation; push polls are defined by intentionally leading question content, not the technology used to deliver them.
- C
- Incorrect because early release of election results is a separate issue (media organizations' decision-making about calling elections); push polls are about manipulative question design, not result release timing.
- D
- Incorrect because limiting polls to party members describes party polling or primary polling, not push polls; push polls are defined by their manipulative question design, not their sample selection.