Ratification was the 1787-1788 fight over whether states would approve the new Constitution. It needed nine of thirteen state conventions to take effect. Federalists like Hamilton, Madison, and Jay argued for it in the Federalist Papers. Anti-Federalists such as Brutus warned the national government would swallow the states and endanger liberty.
Why it matters
The Federalist case explains why the Constitution looks the way it does. The Articles of Confederation could not tax directly, could not regulate commerce, could not pay national debts, and could not raise an army against uprisings like Shays' Rebellion. The Anti-Federalist case explains why the Bill of Rights exists. Federalists promised amendments to win over doubters, and those ten amendments were added in 1791.
How the exam tests it
Expect a table or passage of objections and a question asking what conclusion it supports. The two core Anti-Federalist fears, no bill of rights and loss of state power, will dominate a table of objections. You may also be asked which failures of the Articles the Federalists used to justify a stronger national government.
Don’t confuse it with
Students mix up the two sides' remedies. Anti-Federalists wanted a bill of rights and weaker central power. Federalists wanted a stronger national government and only agreed to a bill of rights as a concession.