The table shows hypothetical data on the objections raised in speeches by delegates who opposed ratifying the Constitution at a state ratifying convention in 1787-1788.
| Main objection raised in speech | Share of opposition speeches |
|---|---|
| Constitution lacks a bill of rights protecting individual liberties | 41% |
| National government would absorb the powers of the states | 33% |
| President could become a monarch | 12% |
| Senate terms are too long | 8% |
| Other objections | 6% |
Which of the following conclusions about the delegates who opposed ratification is best supported by the data in the table?
- AThey mainly objected that the president and Senate would hold too much power
- BTheir most frequent single objection was that the new national government would absorb the powers of the states
- CMost of their objections reflected Anti-Federalist fears about individual liberties and state powerCorrect
- DThey wanted a stronger national government than the proposed Constitution would create
Why C is right
In the table, 41% of opposition speeches objected to the missing bill of rights and 33% warned that the national government would absorb state powers, together 74% of all speeches. Those are the two central Anti-Federalist arguments against ratification: the new national government was too powerful and would threaten state authority, and without a bill of rights it endangered individual liberties. Federalists answered the second concern by promising amendments, which became the Bill of Rights in 1791.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because objections to the president (12%) and the Senate (8%) together make up only 20% of opposition speeches in the table, far less than the objections about individual rights and state power.
- B
- Incorrect because it misreads the table: the threat to state power (33%) was the second most common objection, while the missing bill of rights (41%) was the most frequent single objection.
- D
- Incorrect because the objections in the table all say the national government was too powerful, not too weak; wanting a stronger national government was the Federalist position, not the view of ratification's opponents.