Read the following practice passage.
Before any government existed, each person was free to act as he judged best, yet no one was secure in life or property, since every dispute was settled by force. To escape this danger, people agreed among themselves to give up part of that freedom and to accept the rulings of a common authority. That authority, however, holds its power only as a trust. Its rightful power reaches no further than the purpose for which it was created, and a ruler who turns that power against the people's rights has broken the very agreement that made his rule lawful.
The author of the passage would most likely agree with which of the following statements?
- AGovernment's rightful power comes from people's agreement to give up some natural freedom for security, so that power is limited by the purpose of protecting their rightsCorrect
- BOnce people consent to government, they surrender all natural freedom and may never challenge a ruler who abuses the authority they granted
- CLegitimate authority arises only from a formal written charter that each citizen has personally read, signed, and agreed to obey
- DGovernment exists chiefly to provide public goods and services in exchange for the regular taxes that citizens agree to pay
Why A is right
The passage presents social contract theory as the Enlightenment thinkers who influenced the Founders understood it. Without government, people lacked security ('every dispute was settled by force'), so they 'agreed among themselves to give up part of that freedom' in exchange for a common authority. The passage then limits that authority: power is held 'only as a trust,' it 'reaches no further than the purpose for which it was created,' and a ruler who violates the people's rights 'has broken the very agreement.' Choice A captures both parts of the argument: consent-based legitimacy and power limited by its purpose. B contradicts the passage's conditional view of authority, C treats the agreement as a literal signed document, and D brings in a tax-for-services idea the passage never raises.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- The passage says people give up only 'part of that freedom' and that a ruler who turns power against the people's rights 'has broken the very agreement' that made his rule lawful. This is the opposite of unconditional, irrevocable submission, which is a Hobbes-style misreading of the social contract.
- C
- The passage describes people agreeing 'among themselves' as a theoretical origin of authority. It never mentions a written document that each citizen signs. This reflects the common misconception that the social contract is a literal signed document.
- D
- The passage never mentions taxes or public services. It grounds authority in an exchange of some freedom for security of life, property, and rights, not in a transactional payment-for-services arrangement.