Skip to content
AP U.S. Government and Politics · Interactions Among Branches of Government

Judicial review

Judicial review appears in 25 reviewed AP U.S. Government and Politics questions and sits in Interactions Among Branches of Government. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

The power of courts to declare acts of Congress, the president, or the states unconstitutional and refuse to enforce them. The Constitution's text does not grant it; Chief Justice John Marshall established it in Marbury v. Madison (1803).

Why it matters

Judicial review turns the courts into a real check on the other two branches. Every case that strikes down a law or an executive order, from Marbury onward, including Youngstown (1952), depends on it.

How the exam tests it

Three angles recur. Why Marbury is a landmark: judicial review, not Marbury getting his commission, which the Court refused to order. What threshold question courts ask about an executive order: whether it rests on constitutional or statutory authority without conflicting with a statute. Which presidential action is most likely struck down: one Congress expressly barred.

Don’t confuse it with

Students think Marbury won his case. Marshall said Marbury deserved his commission but ruled that the Court lacked jurisdiction to order it, because Section 13 of the Judiciary Act of 1789 had unconstitutionally expanded the Court's original jurisdiction.

Judicial review in real questions

Example 1Medium
When the president issues an executive order that is challenged in federal court, courts typically ask which key threshold question to determine whether the order is valid?
  1. AWhether the order rests on constitutional or statutory authority without conflicting with a statuteCorrect
  2. BWhether the president personally drafted the order or delegated its drafting to agency officials
  3. CWhether the order received bipartisan support from at least some members of the opposition party in Congress
  4. DWhether the order aligns with the party platform and the campaign promises the president was elected on

Why A is right

Courts evaluating executive orders ask: Is the action within the president's constitutional authority as commander-in-chief or chief executive? If Congress has spoken on the matter, does the order comply with or contradict that statute? Justice Jackson's framework in Youngstown Sheet & Tube v. Sawyer (1952) provides the standard: presidential power is strongest when acting with congressional authorization and weakest when defying it.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Who physically drafts an executive order is irrelevant legally; what matters is whether the authority behind it falls within presidential power.
C
Bipartisan support may be politically relevant but is not a legal requirement; executive orders can be legally valid without any opposition support.
D
Consistency with the party platform or the president's campaign promises is a political consideration, not a legal standard for validity; courts evaluate executive orders against constitutional and statutory law.
Example 2Medium
Marbury v. Madison (1803) is considered a landmark Supreme Court case primarily because Chief Justice Marshall:
  1. AEstablished the principle of judicial review, giving courts the power to invalidate laws that violate the ConstitutionCorrect
  2. BOrdered Secretary of State Madison to deliver Marbury's commission, asserting authority over the executive branch
  3. CRuled that Congress could not expand the Court's original jurisdiction through legislation
  4. DRuled that the President could not be sued while in office, establishing executive immunity

Why A is right

Marbury v. Madison is a landmark case primarily because Chief Justice Marshall established the principle of judicial review — the power of federal courts to declare laws unconstitutional and refuse to enforce them (choice A). The Court did also hold that Section 13 of the Judiciary Act of 1789 unconstitutionally expanded the Court's original jurisdiction (choice C), but that ruling was the vehicle Marshall used to reach the judicial-review holding; it is not why the case is considered a landmark, especially given the stem's 'primarily' framing. Choice B is incorrect because, although Marshall said Marbury had a right to his commission, the Court did NOT order Madison to deliver it — it concluded it lacked jurisdiction to issue the writ of mandamus. Choice D is incorrect because presidential immunity was not addressed in Marbury; it was taken up later in Nixon v. Fitzgerald (1982).
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because the Court never ordered Madison to deliver the commission; Marshall held that Marbury was entitled to it but that the Court lacked jurisdiction to issue the writ of mandamus.
C
Incorrect because while Marshall did rule on the Judiciary Act, this alone understates the decision; the most significant aspect was the establishment of judicial review as a constitutional principle.
D
Incorrect because presidential immunity during office was not established in Marbury; the Court did not reach that question, and Nixon v. Fitzgerald (1982) addressed immunity later.
Example 3Harder
Which of the following scenarios would most likely result in an executive action being struck down by federal courts under separation of powers principles?
  1. AThe president issues an executive order directing agencies to prioritize deporting certain undocumented immigrants in a manner Congress has expressly barred by statuteCorrect
  2. BThe president concludes an executive agreement with Canada guaranteeing reciprocal consular access rather than submitting it to the Senate as a formal treaty for ratification
  3. CThe president issues a proclamation declaring a national emergency and directs FEMA to coordinate federal disaster relief in the aftermath of a catastrophic hurricane
  4. DThe president orders the Secretary of Defense to reorganize the internal command structure of the armed forces without first securing authorization from Congress

Why A is right

Under Justice Jackson's Youngstown framework, when the president acts against the express or implied will of Congress (Category 3), the action is most constitutionally vulnerable. If Congress has explicitly prohibited something by statute and the president acts anyway, the president relies only on inherent Article II powers minus any concurrent congressional power—the weakest possible constitutional position. Courts are most likely to strike down such actions.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because executive agreements are constitutionally recognized and have been used for consular and diplomatic matters for over 200 years; while some argue treaties should require Senate ratification, courts have consistently upheld executive agreements on matters within presidential foreign affairs authority.
C
Incorrect because disaster relief coordination falls squarely within the executive's implementation of congressional emergency management statutes (like the Stafford Act); this is well-established executive authority to implement existing law, not a constitutional overreach.
D
Incorrect because the president, as commander-in-chief, has broad authority over internal military organization and command structures; courts have traditionally shown significant deference to executive military organizational decisions that don't require new appropriations.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Interactions Among Branches of Government.