- AThe shift occurred in 1937, when the Supreme Court struck down dual federalism as unconstitutional, holding that the Supremacy Clause required states to defer to federal authority
- BThe shift occurred gradually between the founding and the Civil War, as the states voluntarily ceded regulatory power to the federal government to promote national unity
- CDual federalism gave way to cooperative federalism only after World War II, when administering veterans' benefits and the GI Bill required joint federal-state programs
- DThe shift occurred during the New Deal era, when the Supreme Court's acceptance of broader Commerce Clause authority enabled federal-state partnerships in social programsCorrect
Why D is right
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The Supreme Court never struck down dual federalism as unconstitutional; its 1937 turn rested on a broader reading of the Commerce Clause, not a Supremacy Clause command that the states defer to federal power.
- B
- States did not voluntarily cede power between the founding and the Civil War; cooperative federalism emerged in the 1930s through New Deal legislation upheld by a changed Supreme Court, not gradual devolution.
- C
- Postwar programs like the GI Bill did rely on federal-state cooperation, but cooperative federalism had already taken hold during the 1930s New Deal, well before World War II.