- A
- Incorrect because the ACA was not struck down. Although a majority agreed the Commerce Clause could not compel individuals to buy insurance, Roberts sustained the mandate under Congress's taxing power, leaving the law in force.
- B
- Incorrect because the mandate was upheld under the taxing power, not the Commerce Clause — Roberts expressly rejected the Commerce Clause rationale — even though states could in fact opt out of the Medicaid expansion.
- D
- Incorrect because the decision was 5-4 rather than unanimous, the mandate rested on the taxing power rather than the Commerce Clause, and the Medicaid expansion was narrowed rather than upheld in full.