Read the following practice passage.
In a large democracy, no single group controls government for long. Farmers, labor unions, manufacturers, environmental advocates, and professional associations all organize to press their demands on lawmakers and agencies. Because each group has some resources but none has enough to win alone, they form shifting coalitions, compete for access, and bargain with one another. The policies that result are rarely what any one group wanted most. Instead, they reflect compromises worked out among many organized interests. On this view, citizens who want to be heard are best served by joining or supporting groups that share their goals.
The argument in the passage best reflects which model of democracy?
- AElite democracy, because a small number of well-funded organizations hold the resources that decide policy outcomes
- BParticipatory democracy, because it stresses that individual citizens take part directly in making policy
- CMajoritarian democracy, because policy follows the preferences of the largest bloc of voters in elections
- DPluralist democracy, because policy emerges from group competitionCorrect
Why D is right
The passage describes many organized interests (farmers, unions, manufacturers, advocates, professional associations) that compete for access, form shifting coalitions, and bargain. Policy comes out as a compromise among them, and no single group dominates. That is the pluralist model of democracy, in which power is spread among competing groups and public policy results from their competition. The passage's advice that citizens join groups to be heard also matches pluralism's focus on groups as the main channel of influence.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Elite theory holds that a small, wealthy minority dominates policy. The passage says the opposite: no single group controls government, and every group has to bargain because none can win alone.
- B
- Participatory democracy stresses broad, direct citizen involvement in decisions. The passage sends citizens' influence through organized groups that bargain with lawmakers, not through direct individual participation.
- C
- A majoritarian model has policy follow the will of most voters. The passage describes policy as compromise among many organized interests, not as the outcome of what an electoral majority prefers.
The table shows hypothetical data from a study of 200 proposed federal policy changes. Each proposal is grouped by whether economic elites (the top 10 percent of earners) and median-income citizens favored or opposed it.
| Preference pattern | Number of proposals | Percent adopted |
|---|---|---|
| Favored by economic elites, opposed by median-income citizens | 40 | 58% |
| Favored by median-income citizens, opposed by economic elites | 40 | 12% |
| Favored by both groups | 60 | 63% |
| Opposed by both groups | 60 | 6% |
Which of the following conclusions about theories of democracy is best supported by the data in the table?
- AThe data are most consistent with elite theory, because proposals backed by economic elites passed at similar rates whether or not median-income citizens agreed, while proposals backed only by median-income citizens rarely passedCorrect
- BThe data are most consistent with pluralism, because proposals with several different groups of supporters were adopted, showing that power is spread among many competing groups
- CThe data are most consistent with participatory democracy, because proposals favored by both economic elites and median-income citizens had the highest adoption rate
- DThe data are most consistent with hyperpluralism, because most proposals in every category failed, showing that competing groups block one another
Why A is right
Elite theory holds that a small, wealthy and powerful group makes most important decisions. Pluralism holds that power is spread among many competing groups. In the table, proposals favored by elites but opposed by median-income citizens were adopted 58% of the time, almost as often as proposals both groups favored (63%). Proposals favored only by median-income citizens were adopted just 12% of the time. Whether a proposal passed depended mostly on what elites wanted, which is what elite theory predicts.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Pluralism predicts that many groups can win on the issues they care about. In the table, median-income citizens rarely got their way against elite opposition (12% adopted), so the data do not show power spread among competing groups.
- C
- Proposals favored by both groups did pass most often (63%), but proposals favored only by elites passed at nearly the same rate (58%). Citizen support added little, so the data do not support participatory democracy, which holds that broad public participation drives outcomes.
- D
- The claim misreads the table. Most elite-favored proposals passed (58% and 63%), so it is false that most proposals in every category failed. The pattern shows one group's preferences winning, not gridlock among many groups.