Read the following practice passage.
In the spring, the president's approval rating stood near 44 percent, held down by a sluggish economy and rising prices. In the week after a foreign attack on a naval base, approval climbed to 71 percent, and leaders of both parties praised the administration's response. Over the next eighteen months, approval slid back below 50 percent. Unemployment rose during that period, and news coverage turned back to domestic issues, even though most commentators still called the military operation that followed the attack a success.
Which of the following conclusions is best supported by the passage?
- AMost of the increase in approval came from opposition-party voters who switched their party identification after the attack.
- BThe gain in approval after the attack faded, as economic conditions again shaped how the public judged the president.Correct
- CApproval of the president tracked the success of the military operation more closely than it tracked the economy.
- DThe attack produced a lasting shift in public support toward the president and the president's party.
Why B is right
The passage shows approval rising sharply right after the attack (from about 44 to 71 percent) and then falling back below 50 percent as unemployment rose and attention returned to domestic issues. That is the 'rally around the flag' pattern: a short surge in presidential approval after a national crisis that fades over time as ordinary concerns such as the economy return. Choice B is the only conclusion that matches both the temporary rise and the later return to economic judgment that the passage describes.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The passage says leaders of both parties praised the response, but it says nothing about voters changing party identification. This choice reads a lasting partisan change into what was a short-term rise in approval.
- C
- The passage says approval fell while the military operation was still seen as a success and unemployment was rising. That pattern fits economic conditions, not the operation's success, driving later approval.
- D
- The passage says approval fell back below 50 percent within eighteen months, so the gain did not last. Calling it a lasting shift misreads the brief spike as a realignment.
Which of the following accurately describes the 'rally around the flag effect' in American politics?
- AThe tendency for citizens of both parties to display patriotic symbols during national holidays, reflecting shared American identity
- BThe political strategy of presidents using patriotic rhetoric and military imagery to distract from domestic policy failures
- CThe tendency for voter turnout to increase dramatically in elections immediately following a major terrorist attack or foreign threat
- DThe short-term increase in presidential approval ratings that typically follows a national security crisis or major military actionCorrect
Why D is right
The rally around the flag effect is the documented pattern of short-term presidential approval boosts following international crises. President Bush's approval ratings surged from ~55% to ~90% after 9/11. The effect is typically short-lived, fading as the situation normalizes or policy failures emerge. It reflects the public tendency to unite behind leadership during perceived national threats.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the rally effect is a political science concept about presidential approval, not a sociological observation about patriotic display during holidays.
- B
- Incorrect because the rally effect describes a documented empirical phenomenon (approval boosts following crises), not a normative description of presidential manipulation strategy.
- C
- Incorrect because while some research shows terrorism fears affect turnout, the rally around the flag effect specifically measures presidential approval, not voter turnout changes.