Skip to content
AP U.S. Government and Politics · Foundations of American Democracy

Virginia Plan

Virginia Plan appears in 3 reviewed AP U.S. Government and Politics questions and sits in Foundations of American Democracy. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

The Virginia Plan was James Madison's blueprint, presented by Edmund Randolph on May 29, 1787, at the Constitutional Convention. It proposed a strong national government with a two-house legislature in which each state's seats in both houses depended on population.

Why it matters

The plan set up the Convention's central fight between large and small states. Its population-based chamber became the House of Representatives after the Great Compromise, and its claim that national authority flows from the people, not the state governments, shaped the whole Constitution.

How the exam tests it

Passage questions describe a delegate arguing that a state with more people deserves more votes, then ask which constitutional feature that argument supports. The answer is a House elected directly by the people and apportioned by population, not the Senate's two votes per state.

Don’t confuse it with

The New Jersey Plan is the near neighbor: it kept one vote per state in a single house to protect small states, while the Virginia Plan tied representation to population and favored large ones.

Virginia Plan in real questions

Example 1Medium
Read the following practice passage, which describes a delegate's argument at the Constitutional Convention. A delegate from a populous state argues that the people, not the state governments, are the true source of the new national government's authority. If a state with ten times as many inhabitants as its smallest neighbor receives the same voice, then the votes of some citizens count for far less than the votes of others. At least one chamber of the national legislature should therefore be chosen directly by the people, and each state's share of seats in that chamber should rise or fall with the number of its inhabitants. Only then, the delegate concludes, will national laws reflect the will of the governed. The delegate's argument most directly supports which feature of the Constitution?
  1. AA Senate in which each state has two members chosen by its state legislature
  2. BA single-chamber Congress in which every state casts one equal vote
  3. CA system in which state legislatures choose the members of both chambers of Congress
  4. DA House of Representatives elected directly by the people, with seats apportioned among the states by populationCorrect

Why D is right

The passage makes two claims. First, authority comes from the people, so at least one chamber should be chosen directly by them. Second, a state's share of seats should rise or fall with its number of inhabitants. Both claims match the House of Representatives in Article I, Section 2: members are elected by the people every two years, and seats are apportioned among the states by population. This was the Virginia Plan principle that survived the Great Compromise. The passage does not support the Senate's equal representation, the Articles' one-state-one-vote Congress, or state legislatures choosing members of both chambers, because each of these gives states equal weight or cuts the people's direct role.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Equal state representation in the Senate, with senators originally chosen by state legislatures, was the small-state position (New Jersey Plan, adopted in the Great Compromise). It is exactly what the delegate objects to: giving a large state and a small state the same voice.
B
A unicameral legislature with one vote per state describes the Articles of Confederation and the New Jersey Plan. The passage argues against equal state votes because they make some citizens' votes count for less.
C
Having state legislatures choose members of both chambers contradicts the passage's claim that the people, not state governments, are the source of authority, and its call for one chamber chosen directly by the people.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Foundations of American Democracy.