On this page · 5 sections
AP U.S. Government has no question called an LEQ. Its long essay is the **Argument Essay**, Question 4 of the free-response section. If a teacher or a study site calls it the LEQ, this is the task they mean.
You get a debatable prompt, no reading passage, and no documents. The prompt lists three foundational documents (sometimes a specific portion of one, such as the First Amendment) and tells you to use evidence from at least one of them. Nothing is supplied. Every fact in your essay comes from memory.
Section II gives you 100 minutes for four FRQs. College Board recommends 40 minutes here and 20 minutes on each of the other three. Section II counts for 50% of your exam score and the four questions carry equal weight, so the Argument Essay is worth 12.5% of the total exam.
The rubric is 6 points across four rows. **Row A, Claim/Thesis (1 pt):** a defensible claim that responds to the prompt and establishes a line of reasoning. **Row B, Evidence (up to 3 pts):** this row counts evidence, nothing else. One piece relevant to the topic earns 1. Either one piece of specific evidence supporting your claim, or two pieces merely relevant to the topic, earns 2. Two pieces of specific evidence supporting your claim, at least one of them from a document the prompt listed, earns 3. **Row C, Reasoning (1 pt):** you use reasoning to explain why the evidence supports your claim. **Row D, Alternate Perspective (1 pt):** you describe an opposing or alternate perspective and rebut or refute it.
Three decision rules run underneath those rows, and students lose points to all three.
Row A gates two other points. You cannot earn the third Row B point without earning Row A, so a missing or non-defensible thesis caps your evidence at 2. You also cannot earn Row D without earning Row A. Rebutting an opposing view brilliantly scores zero if you never staked a claim of your own.
Row C requires at least one piece of specific, relevant evidence. Reasoning with nothing to reason about earns nothing.
Row D does not depend on Rows B or C. Once you have a defensible thesis, a thin evidence section does not block the alternate-perspective point. A rough essay with a real rebuttal beats a polished essay that never names an opposing view.
One more thing about the scoring: it is not holistic. A reader hunts for four specific things and cannot reward style, length, or enthusiasm.
The steps
- 1
Read the prompt twice and mark the three listed documents (1 minute)
The prompt has two halves. The first half is the debatable question — usually built on a verb like *take a position on*, *develop an argument about*, or *explain which best achieves*. The second half is a bulleted list of three foundational documents.
That list is a scoring instruction, not a suggestion. If none of the three appears in your essay, you cannot reach the top of Row B no matter how good your other evidence is. You may bring in additional documents or course content, but at least one of the three must be there and must be described specifically.
Underline the task verb. Circle the three documents. Then ask one question before you plan anything: *which of these three do I actually know the argument of?* Your answer to that question, not your political opinion, decides the shape of the essay.
- 2
Pick the side you can prove, not the side you believe (2 minutes)
No reader knows or cares what you think. Both sides of an AP Gov argument prompt are fully scoreable. The only thing that separates a 6 from a 3 is whether you can attach specific evidence to your claim.
So run a fast test. For each side, count how many concrete things you could name: a clause, a case, a document's actual argument, an institution, a law, a number. Take the side that gets to two fast.
Know the nine required documents cold before exam day, because this step collapses without them: the Declaration of Independence, the Articles of Confederation, the Constitution, Federalist No. 10, Brutus No. 1, Federalist No. 51, Federalist No. 70, Federalist No. 78, and *Letter from a Birmingham Jail*. For each, you need the author, the argument, and one specific mechanism it discusses. Knowing that Federalist No. 10 is "about factions" is not enough. You need Madison's mechanism: a large republic dilutes any single faction and filters opinion through elected representatives.
- 3
Build a five-line plan before you write a word (3 minutes)
Do not outline in paragraphs. Write five lines in the margin:
1. **Claim** — the side, in one clause. 2. **Evidence A** — the listed foundational document, plus the specific thing in it you will describe. 3. **Evidence B** — a second document or a course concept: a case, a clause, a law, an institution. 4. **Reasoning** — the sentence that says why that evidence supports the claim. 5. **Other side** — the strongest opposing claim, and your one-sentence rebuttal of it.
Those five lines map exactly onto the four rubric rows. If you cannot fill line 2 or line 5, you have picked the wrong side — switch now, while switching is free. Three minutes here saves you from the most expensive failure on this question, which is discovering at minute 30 that you have no second piece of evidence.
- 4
Write a thesis someone could argue against (2 minutes)
Row A wants a **defensible claim** with a **line of reasoning**. "Defensible" means a reasonable person could take the other side. "Line of reasoning" means you signal *why*, not just *what*.
A sentence that restates the prompt earns nothing. A sentence that describes both sides fairly and picks neither earns nothing. A sentence like "There are many arguments about the separation of powers" earns nothing.
Use this frame: **[Position], because [the mechanism that makes it true].** The word *because* forces the line of reasoning into existence. One or two sentences is plenty.
Put it in the first paragraph. The rubric allows the claim to sit anywhere in the response, so a thesis in your conclusion still counts. Front-loading is strategy, not a rule: state the claim first and every paragraph after it has something to aim at. It also protects you, because Row A gates the third Row B point and the whole of Row D.
Skip the introduction otherwise. No hook, no historical windup, no definition of democracy. Open with the claim.
- 5
Separate the evidence job (Row B) from the explanation job (Row C)
These are two different rows, and mixing them up costs points in both.
**Row B counts evidence.** Here is the ladder. One piece of evidence merely relevant to the topic earns 1 point. Two topic-relevant pieces, or one piece of specific evidence that actually supports your thesis, earns 2. Two pieces of specific supporting evidence, with at least one from a document the prompt listed, earns 3. That top point also requires Row A, so no thesis means no third point.
Specific means *describe the content*. "Federalist No. 51 discusses checks and balances" is a title with a topic attached. "In Federalist No. 51, Madison argues that each branch must be given both the constitutional tools and the self-interest to resist the others, so that competing ambitions hold each other in place" is specific evidence. It states a claim the document actually makes.
**Row C is the explanation.** One point, and the bar is lower than students assume: explaining how one piece of your evidence supports your argument is enough to earn it. You need at least one piece of specific, relevant evidence for the row to be available at all.
Write that explanation as its own sentence and start it with *this shows that*, *this matters because*, or *therefore*. Do not assume the connection is obvious. Readers score what is on the page.
Advice, not rubric: run one paragraph per piece of evidence and keep both explanations pointed at the same claim. The rubric does not require a line of reasoning sustained across the whole essay — that is the APUSH and AP World LEQ standard, not this one. But an essay that drifts into a general survey of the topic tends to lose the thesis, and losing the thesis costs you Row A, the third Row B point, and Row D.
- 6
Rebut the other side; do not just mention it
Row D is a full sixth of the score and the point most often left on the table. "Some people disagree" gets you nothing. The row requires two moves in sequence, and it requires a Row A thesis to be eligible at all.
First, **describe the opposing perspective specifically**, ideally with its own evidence: name what the other side would point to. Second, **rebut or refute it**. Those are the two routes the rubric recognizes. *Refutation:* the opposing claim is wrong, and here is why. *Rebuttal:* the evidence is real but does not prove what they say it proves.
The concede-then-limit move still works, but it is not a third route. It scores only when the "but" clause does the rebuttal work — you grant the fact, then show it does not overturn your claim. Stop after "they have a point" and you have simply agreed with your opponent, which earns nothing.
Give this its own paragraph, four or five sentences, near the end. Write it before your conclusion — if time runs out, you want to lose the conclusion, which is worth zero points, not this.
- 7
Spend the last three minutes checking rows, not commas
Stop writing with three minutes left and audit against the rubric, in order.
Row A: can you point to one sentence that takes a side and could be argued against? Row B: are there two pieces of specific evidence, and is at least one of them from a document the prompt listed? Row C: is there at least one sentence explaining why a piece of your evidence supports your claim? Row D: is there a named opposing perspective *and* a rebuttal or refutation of it?
If a row is missing, fix that row. Row A first, always — it gates the third Row B point and all of Row D, so one missing thesis sentence can cost three points.
Do not fix spelling, do not add a conclusion, do not extend a paragraph you already scored. Readers do not deduct for grammar, handwriting, or an essay that stops abruptly. A missing Row D costs a full point. A comma splice costs nothing.
One optional check if you have seconds left, and it is advice rather than a scored requirement: do your explanations argue for the same claim, or did the second one wander?
Worked through
**Prompt (written for this guide):** Take a position on whether the constitutional separation of powers still limits presidential power effectively. Back your argument with at least one specific piece of evidence drawn from Federalist No. 51, Federalist No. 70, or the Constitution.
**The five-line plan (3 minutes)**
1. Claim: it no longer limits the president effectively, because the checks Madison designed run through branches while modern politics runs through parties. 2. Evidence A (listed doc): Federalist No. 51 — branch-based ambition. 3. Evidence B (course concept): the veto override and impeachment thresholds in practice. 4. Reasoning: a check that requires a supermajority only works if loyalty is institutional, not partisan. 5. Other side: the Senate's advice-and-consent power and judicial review still block presidents — grant that they bite, then rebut by showing they are episodic.
**The essay**
*Thesis (Row A).* The separation of powers no longer effectively limits presidential power, because the Constitution assigned its checks to branches while political loyalty in the modern era runs through parties, leaving the strongest restraints unusable whenever the president's party holds Congress.
*Paragraph 1 — Evidence A + explanation.* Federalist No. 51 rests on an assumption about human motive. Madison argued that each branch had to be given both the constitutional means and the personal incentive to resist encroachment by the others, so that ambition would counteract ambition and no branch could accumulate all power. The design assumes a member of Congress identifies first as a member of Congress. **This matters because the incentive Madison counted on has shifted.** A representative who shares the president's party gains little from defending congressional turf and a great deal from protecting the president, so the personal motive that was supposed to power the check now often points the other way.
*Paragraph 2 — Evidence B + explanation.* The Constitution's hardest checks on the president are supermajority checks. Article I, Section 7 lets Congress override a veto only with two-thirds of both chambers, and removal after impeachment requires two-thirds of the Senate. **Those thresholds show the problem.** Fewer than one in ten presidential vetoes in American history has been overridden, and no president has ever been convicted and removed by the Senate — every presidential impeachment trial has ended in acquittal. Against a president, a check that has never once produced its intended outcome is not restraining behavior; it is being survived.
*Reasoning (Row C).* Both pieces point at the same mechanism. Madison's system works only when a legislator's institutional identity outweighs every other loyalty, because only then will enough members cross party lines to reach two-thirds. Once party identity dominates, the supermajority requirement stops being a high bar for a lawless president and becomes a guarantee of survival for a partisan one.
*Alternate perspective (Row D).* A strong counterargument says the checks still bite. The Senate can reject or bury a president's nominees under the advice-and-consent power in Article II, Section 2, and federal courts routinely strike down executive orders as exceeding statutory or constitutional authority. **Those checks are real and they land.** But they are episodic and reactive, which is why they do not amount to the restraint Madison described. They arrive after a president has already acted. They depend on which party happens to hold the Senate. They reach appointments and individual orders rather than the president's ongoing command of the executive branch. Blocking one nominee is not continuous structural restraint.
**Why this scores 6.** Row A: the thesis picks a side and gives a *because*, which also unlocks the top Row B point and Row D. Row B (3 pts): two pieces of specific evidence supporting the claim — Federalist No. 51's actual argument, from the prompt's list, and the Constitution's supermajority thresholds with concrete outcomes. Row C (1 pt): the explanation sentences that say why that evidence supports the thesis; the one after Federalist No. 51 alone would earn the point. Row D (1 pt): a named opposing perspective with its own evidence, rebutted — the "but they are episodic and reactive" move grants the fact and then denies that it proves what the other side needs it to prove.
**Note the length.** This is under 600 words. There is no introduction and no conclusion. Nothing here is decorative.
Common mistakes
Writing a balanced thesis that surveys both sides and commits to neither. Row A requires a defensible claim, and "there are strong arguments on both sides" is not one. This is the most expensive mistake on the question: no Row A means no third Row B point and no Row D, so one weak sentence can cost three.
Naming a foundational document without describing anything in it. "Federalist No. 78 is about the judiciary" is a topic label. At best that is topic-relevant evidence worth a low Row B score. To be specific, state a claim the document actually makes — Hamilton's argument that the judiciary controls neither the purse nor the sword and so depends on judgment alone.
Ignoring the prompt's list of three documents and using a different one. Extra documents are welcome, but the third Row B point requires at least one from the list. Check the list before you commit to a plan.
Stacking evidence with no explanation attached. Two well-described documents still score Row B, but zero sentences connecting them to the thesis loses Row C outright. You only need one — write at least one sentence that says why a piece of your evidence supports your claim.
Reducing the alternate perspective to a throwaway line like "of course, others disagree." Row D needs a specific opposing perspective and then a rebuttal or refutation of it. Granting a point and stopping there does not score; the "but" clause is what turns a concession into a rebuttal.
Spending ten minutes on an introduction and conclusion that restate the prompt. Neither earns a point. That time is why students run out of clock before writing the alternate-perspective paragraph, which is worth a full sixth of the score.
Checklist
- Can you name all nine required foundational documents, and for each one state the author, the central argument, and one specific mechanism it describes?
- Can you write a thesis in one sentence that takes a side and contains the word *because*, in under 90 seconds?
- Can you say which two points you lose automatically if that thesis is missing or non-defensible?
- Can you climb the Row B ladder from memory — what earns 1 point, what earns 2, and what earns 3?
- Can you tell the difference between supplying evidence (Row B) and explaining why it supports your claim (Row C), and produce both as separate sentences?
- Can you look at a prompt's three-document list and say which one you know well enough to describe specifically, before you choose your position?
- Can you write an alternate-perspective paragraph that names the opposing claim, supplies evidence for it, and then rebuts or refutes it?
- Can you build the five-line plan — claim, evidence A, evidence B, reasoning, other side — in three minutes flat?
- Can you audit a finished essay against the four rubric rows in under three minutes and name which row, if any, is missing?
- Can you finish the whole essay in 40 minutes without writing an introduction or a conclusion?