"The American Anti-Imperialist League, founded 1898: Prominent members included Mark Twain, Andrew Carnegie, Jane Addams, and Samuel Gompers. The League opposed American annexation of the Philippines, arguing that governing a distant people without their consent violated American democratic principles and the Declaration of Independence."
— Modern description of the Anti-Imperialist League
The Anti-Imperialist League's argument most directly challenged which aspect of the case for American imperialism?
- AThe humanitarian argument that American rule would benefit Filipino peoples by ending Spanish misrule, since anti-imperialists believed American rule would be equally exploitative
- BThe economic argument that colonies would provide new markets for American manufactured goods, which anti-imperialists argued was economically incorrect because colonies were expensive to maintain
- CThe military argument that Pacific island possessions would strengthen American naval power, which anti-imperialists argued was strategically unnecessary since the United States had sufficient domestic security
- DThe claim that American democratic values were compatible with governing distant peoples without their consent, which anti-imperialists argued was a fundamental contradiction of American founding principlesCorrect
Why D is right
The Anti-Imperialist League's central argument was a principled one about self-governance and democratic consent: that the Declaration of Independence's principles — that governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed — were fundamentally incompatible with governing Filipinos as colonial subjects without their agreement. Mark Twain's savage anti-imperialist essays (including 'The War Prayer') made this point most eloquently: America could not be both a democracy at home and an empire abroad without betraying its own founding values. This argument also often carried, unfortunately, a racist undercurrent arguing that non-white peoples were ungovernable and would corrupt American democracy.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because while some anti-imperialists did raise humanitarian concerns about American colonial rule, the primary argument identified in the passage — and historically most characteristic of the League — was the democratic principles argument about governing without consent.
- B
- Incorrect because while anti-imperialists did make economic arguments, the primary and most distinctive argument of the Anti-Imperialist League was the democratic-principles argument about consent and self-governance, not primarily an economic one.
- C
- Incorrect because the anti-imperialists' challenge was primarily moral and principled rather than strategic; they were arguing against imperialism as a violation of American values, not primarily making strategic calculations about naval necessity.