Skip to content
AP U.S. History · Period 5: 1844-1877

Black military service

Black military service appears in 3 reviewed AP U.S. History questions and sits in Period 5: 1844-1877. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

The enlistment of roughly 179,000 Black men in the Union army, about one in ten Union soldiers, plus some 19,000 in the navy. The Militia Act of July 1862 opened the door, the Emancipation Proclamation widened it, and War Department General Order 143 of May 22, 1863 set up the Bureau of Colored Troops to organize the regiments.

Why it matters

It made the war a war against slavery in practice, supplied manpower as white enlistment fell off, and gave Black Americans a concrete argument for citizenship that they pressed through Reconstruction and beyond.

How the exam tests it

Expect stems that ask what Black enlistment did to the Union war effort and to its purpose. Aim your answer at manpower arriving as white volunteering dried up, and at a war for the Union turning into a war against slavery.

Don’t confuse it with

The Confederacy used enslaved labor to dig fortifications and haul supplies throughout the war, but it did not authorize Black soldiers until March 1865, far too late to affect the outcome.

Black military service in real questions

Example 1Medium
"We the undersigned members of Company C...do hereby protest against the unequal pay given to us as soldiers of the United States Army. We were promised equal pay with white troops when we enlisted. We therefore respectfully but firmly decline to receive the pay offered until our rights are given us." —Petition of African American soldiers, 54th Massachusetts Infantry, 1863 Which of the following most directly explains the significance of this protest?
  1. AIt demonstrates that African American soldiers refused to perform any military duties or enter combat until the federal government guaranteed them full legal and social equality
  2. BIt reveals that the Emancipation Proclamation had immediately ended all forms of racial discrimination within the federal government, the army, and other Union institutions
  3. CIt illustrates how African American soldiers used military service to demand equal citizenship, challenging racial hierarchies within the Union war effort itselfCorrect
  4. DIt shows that the Union Army had fully integrated its officer corps, placing African American troops under the command of Black officers with the same authority as white leaders

Why C is right

The 54th Massachusetts' pay protest—refusing $10/month (the rate for Black soldiers) versus $13/month for white soldiers—exemplified how African American troops actively fought for equal citizenship even within the constraints of military service. Their protest eventually contributed to Congress equalizing pay in 1864. This reflects historian Jim McPherson's argument that Black soldiers saw military service as a pathway to citizenship.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the soldiers continued to serve and fight even while protesting unequal pay; Sergeant William Carney famously carried the flag at Battery Wagner while this dispute was ongoing.
B
Incorrect because the Emancipation Proclamation addressed the status of enslaved people in Confederate states, not racial discrimination within Union institutions.
D
Incorrect because the Union Army maintained racial hierarchy in its officer corps; Black regiments were primarily led by white officers, though some Black men served as junior officers.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Period 5: 1844-1877.