"When Confederate forces fired on Fort Sumter in April 1861, four more slave states — Virginia, Arkansas, Tennessee, and North Carolina — seceded to join the Confederacy. Four slave states — Missouri, Kentucky, Maryland, and Delaware — remained in the Union. Lincoln's handling of the border states was crucial: he suspended habeas corpus in Maryland to prevent secession, and he worked carefully to avoid offending Kentucky's slaveholding Unionists." — Civil War border states, 2008
Which of the following best explains why the author expressed this viewpoint about Lincoln's handling of the border states?
- ATo argue that the loyalty of the border states was militarily irrelevant to the Union, since their populations were small, their industrial output minimal, and their strategic location of no consequence to the larger war effort
- BTo show that Lincoln would use unconstitutional means and tolerate slavery where necessary to preserve the Union, revealing the pragmatic limits of his antislavery commitmentCorrect
- CTo show that Lincoln's diplomatic failures alienated the border states and drove several of them to secede, adding substantially to the Confederacy's territory, population, and war-making resources
- DTo demonstrate that Lincoln's suspension of habeas corpus enjoyed the unanimous backing of the Supreme Court, which upheld each of his wartime emergency measures as a fully constitutional exercise of executive power
Why B is right
Lincoln's handling of the border states illustrates the pragmatic constraints on his antislavery principles: to keep Maryland (which surrounded Washington D.C.) in the Union, he suspended habeas corpus and arrested secessionists without trial; to retain Kentucky's Unionists, he initially avoided threatening slavery where it was legal. This pragmatism — tolerating slavery temporarily to preserve the Union — shows that Lincoln's war aims were initially about union rather than abolition, and that constitutional guarantees were suspended when he deemed military necessity required it.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the border states were critically important: Maryland surrounded Washington D.C.; Kentucky controlled access to the Tennessee and Cumberland river systems; Missouri controlled the upper Mississippi; losing any of them would have been militarily catastrophic for the Union.
- C
- Incorrect because none of the border states Lincoln was handling — Maryland, Kentucky, Missouri, Delaware — ultimately seceded; Lincoln's diplomacy and coercion kept them in the Union; the passage describes his successful retention of these states, not his failures.
- D
- Incorrect because the Supreme Court did not unanimously uphold Lincoln's habeas corpus suspension; Chief Justice Taney, in Ex parte Merryman (1861), ruled that only Congress could suspend habeas corpus; Lincoln ignored the ruling, illustrating the limits of judicial enforcement against a determined executive during wartime.