"The Erie Canal, completed in 1825, connected the Hudson River at Albany to Lake Erie at Buffalo — 363 miles of artificial waterway through the wilderness of upstate New York. The canal reduced freight costs from Buffalo to New York City by approximately 95% and travel time by 75%. New York City's commercial dominance of American commerce was the result: it became the nation's largest city and busiest port, eclipsing Boston, Philadelphia, and Baltimore." — Market Revolution transportation history, 2007
Which of the following most directly contributed to the perspective expressed in this passage?
- AThe superior geographic position of New York City, which would have dominated American commerce regardless of canal construction owing to its naturally deep harbor and access to European shipping routes
- BBritish investment in the Erie Canal as part of Britain's deliberate commercial strategy to control American interior trade through New York rather than through the rival ports of Philadelphia and Baltimore
- CNew York State's decision to fund canal construction with state bonds after Congress declined to finance national internal improvements, giving New York a commercial edge over rival states still awaiting federal aidCorrect
- DFederal government investment in the Erie Canal under Henry Clay's American System, a program that funded internal improvements across multiple states to bind them into a single national market
Why C is right
The Erie Canal was funded by New York State, not the federal government. When Congress failed to pass a comprehensive internal improvements program, New York Governor DeWitt Clinton persuaded the state legislature to fund the canal through state bonds. This state investment, completed while other eastern states waited for federal action that never came, gave New York City an overwhelming commercial advantage in accessing the rapidly developing interior — transforming it into the nation's commercial capital.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because New York City had significant commercial advantages before the canal but was not yet dominant; Philadelphia and Boston were serious competitors, and the canal was the decisive factor in New York's commercial triumph over rival cities, not merely a reflection of existing geographic advantages.
- B
- Incorrect because there was no British investment strategy behind the Erie Canal; it was financed through New York State bond issues purchased primarily by American and some British investors in the bond markets, but it was not a deliberate British commercial scheme.
- D
- Incorrect because the Erie Canal was state-funded, not federally funded; Henry Clay's American System proposed federal funding for internal improvements, but Congress (particularly under Southern opposition) failed to consistently fund such projects, and the Erie Canal specifically was a New York State project.