"The Whiskey Rebellion, 1794: Western Pennsylvania farmers, who turned their grain into whiskey because it was far easier to transport than bulk grain over the Appalachian Mountains, refused to pay Hamilton's excise tax on distilled spirits. They tarred and feathered tax collectors, attacked the home of a federal inspector, and organized armed resistance. Washington responded by leading 13,000 troops into western Pennsylvania."
— Modern account of the Whiskey Rebellion
The federal government's response to the Whiskey Rebellion most directly demonstrated which of the following?
- AThe new national government's determination and capacity to enforce federal law and suppress armed resistance, establishing its authorityCorrect
- BThe weakness of the new constitutional government, which needed the president himself to lead troops because it had no standing army
- CWashington's sympathy with frontier farmers' grievances, which led him to negotiate a settlement granting the distillers tax relief
- DThe excessive use of military force by Federalist leaders, who exploited the unrest as a pretext to crush political opposition to Hamilton's economic program
Why A is right
The federal government's overwhelming military response to the Whiskey Rebellion — mobilizing 13,000 troops under Washington's personal command, larger than most Revolutionary War armies — was a deliberate demonstration of the new constitutional government's authority and will to enforce federal law. Unlike under the Articles of Confederation (which could not suppress Shays' Rebellion without state cooperation), the new government could directly raise and deploy military force. The rebellion collapsed without significant violence, and Washington pardoned the participants, demonstrating both the government's power and its restraint.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the Whiskey Rebellion actually demonstrated federal strength rather than weakness; the government successfully mobilized a massive military force and suppressed the rebellion, the opposite of the Articles' inability to respond to Shays' Rebellion.
- C
- Incorrect because Washington led troops as a military demonstration of federal authority, not as a gesture of sympathy or to negotiate tax relief; the tax remained in place and the purpose was to enforce it, not to abolish it.
- D
- Incorrect because while Democratic-Republicans criticized the response as disproportionate, characterizing it as 'excessive' or as crushing 'political opposition' overstates the case; the rebellion involved genuine armed resistance and violence against federal officials, justifying a forceful federal response.